The 9X100 Positional Ranking Lists

Categorization of Position

Defender : Some players in the pre-war era is a half way between SB and CB so it is depend on their style of ability to be considered in the category.

Central Midfielder : To separate DM and AM, the solution sets DM include destroyer and box-to-box midfielder (CM)(players who balance between defense and offence and not much creative force).

Playmaker : The list includes the pure deep-lying playmakers and basic playmakers only.

Trequartista : Most inside-forwards in the 1st half of 20th century and are considered as Trequartista. For the 2nd half of 20th century, most players are considered as Trequartista should be back up by two central midfielders.

Forward : Most forwards are selected in this list played just behind target striker but some center-forwards are considered in this thread due to their style of play.

Striker : The list include strikers are mainly set as finisher role, could be divided into Fast Striker and Target Striker. They are basically a prolific scorer. For players in pre-war era, it is known that a ton of goals is easier to make so players' place is depend on how much did they outstanding in their time.
____________________________________

The 100 Greatest Goalkeepers of All-Time

1. Lev Yashin (Soviet Union)
2. Dino Zoff (Italy)
3. Gianluigi Buffon (Italy)
4. Gordon Banks (England)
5. Peter Schmeichel (Denmark)
6. Sepp Maier (Germany)
7. Ricardo Zamora (Spain)
8. Oliver Kahn (Germany)
9. Peter Shilton (England)
10. Ubaldo Fillol (Argentina)
11. Iker Casillas (Spain)
12. Rinat Dasaev (Soviet Union)
13. Ladislao Mazurkiewicz (Uruguay)
14. Pat Jennings (Northern Ireland)
15. Edwin Van Der Sar (Holland)
16. Gilmar (Brazil)
17. Harald Schumaccher (Germany)   
18. Frantisek Planicka (Czechoslovakia)
19. Jean Marie-Pfaff (Belgium)
20. Walter Zenga (Italy)
21. Manuel Neuer (Germany)
22. Jurgen Croy (Germany)
23. Vladimir Beara (Yugoslavia)
24. Enrico Albertosi (Italy)  
24. Michel Preud'Homme (Belgium)
26. Amadeo Carrizo (Argentina)
27. Gianpiero Combi (Italy)
28. Jose Luis Chilavert (Paraguay)
29. Andoni Zubizarreta (Spain) 
30. Ray Clemence (England) 
31. Jose Angel Iribar (Spain) 
32. Peter Cech (Czech Republic)
33. Gianluca Pagliuca (Italy)
34. Ronnie Hellstrom (Sweden)
35. Ivo Viktor (Czechoslovakia)
36. Thomas Ravelli (Sweden)
37. Neville Southall (Wales)
38. Andreas Kopke (Germany) 
39. Hans Van Breukelen (Holland)
40. Emerson Leao (Brazil)
41. Jan Van Beveren (Holland)
42. Gyula Grosics (Hungary)
43. Roque Maspoli (Uruguay)
44. Antonio Ramallets (Spain)
45. Hans Tilkowski (Germany)
46. Luis Arconada (Spain)
47. Evhen Rudakov (Soviet Union)
48. Rudolph Hiden (Austria)
49. Heinrich Stuhlfauth (Germany)
50. Jan Tomaszewski (Poland)
51. Franjo Glaser (Yugoslavia)
52. Bert Trautmann (Germany)
53. Walter Zeman (Austria)  
54. Samuel Hardy (England)
55. Villiam Schrojf (Czechoslovakia)
56. Americo Tesoriere (Argentina)
57. Frank Swift (England)
58. Claudio Taffarel (Brazil)
59. Angelo Peruzzi (Italy)
60. Francesco Toldo (Italy)
61. Lorenzo Buffon (Italy)
62. Milutin Soskic (Yugoslavia)
63. Fabien Barthez (France)
64. Sergio Livingstone (Chile)
65. Jack Kelsey (Wales)
66. Jozsef Mylnalcyk (Poland)
67. Giuliano Sarti (Italy)
68. Christian Piot (Belgium)
69. Aldo Oliveri (Italy)
70. Karoly Zsak (Hungary)
71. Rogelio Dominguez (Argentina)
72. Elisha Scott (Ireland Republic)
73. Ivan Curkovic (Yugoslavia)
74. Andres Mazali (Uruguay)
75. Antonio Carbajal (Mexico)
76. Karl Oscar Svensson (Sweden)
77. Thomas N'kono (Cameroon)
78. Antonio Roma (Argentina)
79. Rustu Recber (Turkey)
80. Hugo Gatti (Argentina)
81. Frans De Munck (Holland)
82. Bodo Iligner (Germany) 
83. Joel Bats (France)
84. Moacir Barbosa (Brazil)
85. Uli Stein (Germany) 
86. Juan Valdivieso (Peru)
87. Manuel Bento (Portugal)
88. Harry Gregg (Northern Ireland) 
89. Vitor Baia (Portugal)
90. David Seaman (England)
91. Sergio Goycochea (Argentina)
92. Carlos Jose Castilho (Brazil)
93. Leigh Richmond Roose (Wales)
94. Julio Cesar Soares (Brazil)
95. Hans Jakob (Germany)
96. Manga (Brazil) 
97. Rodolfo Rodriguez (Uruguay)
98. Roberto Rojas (Chile)
99. Stefano Tacconi (Italy)
100. Jens Lehmann (Germany)

Reserved List

Francisco Buyo (Spain)
Joao Avezedo (Portugal)
Augustin Cejas (Argentina)
Eike Immel (Germany)
Jean De Bie (Belgium)
Luciano Castellini (Italy)
Norbert Nigbur (Germany)
Friedrich Herkenrath (Germany)
Vitor Damas (Portugal)
Santiago Canizares (Spain)
Pierre Chayrigues (France)

Stats By Nation

13 : Germany 
11 : Italy 
7 : Argentina, Brazil
6 : Spain 
5 : England 
4 : Czechoslovakia, Yugoslavia, Uruguay 
3: Soviet Union, Belgium, Sweden, Wales 
2: Portugal, Austria, Hungary, France, Poland, Chile, Northern Ireland
1: Ireland Republic, Cameroon,Turkey, Denmark, Paraguay, Peru, Mexico
____________________________________


The 100 Greatest Defensive Laterals of All-Time

1. Paolo Maldini (Italy)
2. Giacinto Facchetti (Italy)
3. Nilton Santos (Brazil)
4. Ruud Krol (Holland)
5. Djalma Santos (Brazil)
6. Berti Vogts (Germany)
7. Lilian Thuram (France)
8. Roberto Carlos (Brazil)
9. Antonio Cabrini (Italy)
10. Leovegildo Junior (Brazil)
11. Carlos Alberto (Brazil)
12. Karlheinz Schnellinger (Germany)
13. Andreas Brehme (Germany)
14. Javier Zanetti (Argentina)
15. Marcos Cafu (Brazil)
16. Hans Peter Briegel (Germany)
17. Paul Janes (Germany)
18. Silvio Marzolini (Argentina)
19. Manuel Amoros (France)
20. Victor Rodriguez Andrade (Uruguay)
21. Phillip Lahm (Germany)
22. Renzo De Vecchi (Italy)
23. Danny Mcgrain (Scotland)
24. Jose Antonio Camacho (Spain)
25. Branko Stankovic (Yugoslavia)
26. Maxime Bossis (France)
27. Bixente Lizarazu (France)
28. Sergio Cervato (Italy)
29. Manfred Kaltz (Germany)
30. Leandro Ferreira (Brazil)
31. Alfredo Foni (Italy)
32. Jorginho (Brazil)
33. Daniel Alves (Brazil)
34. Eric Gerets (Belgium)
35. Tarcisio Burgnich (Italy)
36. Marinho Chagas (Brazil)
37. Karl Sesta (Austria)
38. Fahrudin Jusufi (Yugoslavia)
39. Joan Segarra (Spain)
40. Anatoliy Demyanenko (Soviet Union)
41. Rafael Gordillo (Spain)
42. Nelinho (Brazil)
43. Vladimir Bessonov (Soviet Union)
44. Jimmy Armfield (England)
45. Luis Eyzaguirre (Chile)
46. Eddie Hapgood (England)
47. Phil Neal (England)
48. Gianluca Zambrotta (Italy)
49. Erik Nilsson (Sweden)
50. Maicon Douglas (Brazil)   
51. Schubert Gambetta (Uruguay)
52. Johnny Carey (Ireland Republic)
53. Branco (Brazil)
54. Eraldo Monzeglio (Italy)
55. Carlos Sosa (Argentina)
56. Armand Swartenbroeks (Belgium)
57. Umberto Caligaris (Italy)
58. Luigi Allemandi (Italy)
59. Klaus Urbanczyk (East Germany)   
60. Francisco Arce (Paraguay)
61. Ashley Cole (England)
62. Billy McCracken (Northern Ireland)
63. Fred Keenor (Wales)
64. Orvar Bergmark (Sweden)
65. Horst-Dieter Hottges (Germany)
66. Evgeny Lovchev (Soviet Union)
67. Erich Juskowiak (Germany)
68. Patrick Battiston (France)
69. Wim Suurbier (Holland)
70. Ricardo Pavoni (Uruguay)
71. Christian Panucci (Italy)
72. Bernard Dietz (Germany)
73. Kenny Sansom (England)
74. Stefan Reuter (Germany)
75. Juan Pablo Sorin (Argentina)
76. Branislav Ivanovic (Yugoslavia)
77. Ladislav Novak (Czechoslovakia)
78. Arthur Correia (Portugal)
79. Roger Marche (France)
80. Aleksandar Shalamanov (Bulgaria)
81. Antonello Cuccureddu (Italy)
82. Sandy Jardine (Scotland)
83. Hilario (Portugal)
84. Joclyn Angloma (France)
85. Fritz Tarp (Denmark)
86. Alberto Tarantini (Argentina)
87. Stuart Pearce (England)
88. Patrice Evra (France)
89. Roger Byrne (England)
90. Karol Dobias (Czechoslovakia)
91. Ray Wilson (England)
92. Jorge Olguin (Argentina)
93. Terry Cooper (England)
94. Sandor Biro (Hungary)
95. Nilton De Sordi (Brazil)
96. Joao Pinto (Portugal)
97. Antoni Szymanowski (Poland)
98. Vladimir Durkovic (Yugoslavia)
99. Viv Anderson (England)
100. Ferenc Rudas (Hungary)

Reserved List

George Hardwick (England)
Jorge Carrascosa (Argentina)
George Young (Scotland)
Felice Gasperi (Italy)
Mihaly Lantos (Hungary)
Mauro Tassotti (Italy)
Enrique Wolff (Argentina)
Dan Petrescu (Romania)
Howard Spencer (England)

Stats By Nation

14 : Brazil 
12 : Germany, Italy 
10 : England 
8 : France 
7 : Argentina
5 : Yugoslavia
4 : Portugal
3 : Soviet Union, Spain
2 : Czechoslovakia, Sweden, Belgium, Uruguay, Holland, Scotland, Hungary 
1 : Ireland Republic, Northern Ireland, Chile, Paraguay, Bulgaria 
     Austria, Denmark, Wales, Uruguay, Poland 
____________________________________


The 100 Greatest Central Defenders of All-Time

1. Franz Beckenbauer (Germany)
2. Franco Baresi (Italy)
3. Bobby Moore (England)
4. Daniel Passarella (Argentina)
5. Gaetano Scirea (Italy)
6. Elias Figueroa (Chile)
7. Alessandro Nesta (Italy)
8. Matthias Sammer (Germany)
9. Hector Chumpitaz (Peru)
10. Domingos Da Guia (Brazil)
11. Ronald Koeman (Holland)
12. Jurgen Kohler (Germany)
13. Giuseppe Bergomi (Italy)
14. Jose Nasazzi (Uruguay)
15. Jose Santamaria (Uruguay)
16. Fabio Cannavaro (Italy)
17. Billy Wright (England)
18. Fernando Hierro (Spain)
19. Claudio Gentile (Italy)
20. Karlheinz Forster (Germany)   
21. Alan Hansen (Scotland)
22. Marcel Desailly (France)
23. Laurent Blanc (France)
24. Albert Shesternev (Soviet Union)
25. Ciro Ferrara (Italy)
26. Velibor Vasovic (Yugoslavia)
27. Pietro Vierchowod (Italy)
28. Oscar Ruggeri (Argentina)
29. Willi Schulz (Germany)
30. Alessandro Costacurta (Italy)
31. Jacinto Quincoces (Spain)
32. Murtaz Khurtsilava (Soviet Union)
33. Roberto Perfumo (Argentina)
34. Jan Popluhar (Czechoslovakia)
35. Luis Pereira (Brazil)
36. Marius Tresor (France)
37. Robert Jonquet (France)
38. Jaap Stam (Holland)
39. Branco Zebec (Yugoslavia)
40. Virginio Rosetta (Italy)
41. Gheorghe Popescu (Romania)
42. Germano (Portugal)
43. Bruno Pezzey (Austria)
44. Morten Olsen (Denmark)
45. Nemanja Vidic (Serbia)
46. Hans Jurgen Dorner (Germany)
47. Reinhold Munzenburg (Germany)
48. Wladislaw Zmuda (Poland)
49. Wolfgang Weber (Germany)
50. Guillermo Delgado (Peru)  
51. Edinho (Brazil)
52. Niel Franklin (England)
53. Cor Van De Hart (Holland)
54. John Terry (England)
55. Roberto Ayala (Argentina)
56. Tony Adams (England)
57. Rune Bratseth (Norway)
58. Sol Campbell (England)
59. Dragan Holcer (Yugoslavia)
60. Alexandru Apolzan (Romania)
61. Mauro Ramos (Brazil)
62. Lucio (Brazil)
63. Humberto Coelho (Portugal)
64. Rio Ferdinand (England)
65. Julio Melendez (Peru)
66. Carles Puyol (Spain)
67. Ernst Happel (Austria)
68. Pietro Rava (Italy)  
69. Armando Picchi (Italy)
70. Fulvio Collovati (Italy)
71. Bob Crompton (England)
72. Anton Ondrus (Czechoslovakia)
73. Severino Minelli (Switzerland)
74. Alexander Chivadze (Soviet Union)
75. Dario Pereyra (Uruguay)
76. Paul Mcgrath (Ireland)
77. Gyula Lorant (Hungary)
78. Guido Buchwald (Germany)
79. Jesus Garay Vecino (Spain)
80. Sami Hyypia (Finland)
81. Jose Migueli (Spain)
82. Sergio Ramos (Spain)
83. Jose Salomon (Argentina)
84. Ricardo Carvalho (Portugal)
85. Anatoli Bashashkin (Soviet Union)
86. Aldair (Brazil)
87. Karoly Fogl (Hungary)
88. Jose Ramos Delgado (Argentina)
89. Josip Katalinski (Yugoslavia)              
90. Jack Charlton (England)
91. Vincent Kompany (Belgium)
92. Milutin Ivkovic (Yugoslavia)
93. Rinus Israel (Holland)
94. Ivan Horvat (Yugoslavia)
95. Hilderaldo Bellini (Brazil)
96. Terry Butcher (England)
97. Frank De Boer (Holland)
98. Thiago Silva (Brazil)
99. Dimitar Penev (Bulgaria) 
100. Roy Mcfarland (England)

Reserved List

Vagiz Khidiatullin (Soviet Union)  
Miodrag Belodedici (Romania)
Cornel Dinu (Romania) Carlos Gamarra (Paraguay)
Laurent Verbiest (Belgium)
Costica Stefanescu (Romania)
Kalman Meszoly (Hungary)
Mustapha Zitouni (Algeria)
Riccardo Ferri (Italy)
Ricardo Gomes (Brazil)
Anatoli Maslyonkin (Soviet Union)
Walter Samuel (Argentina)
Des Walker (England)
Jerzy Gorgon (Poland)

Stats by Nation

12 : Italy 
10 : England 
9 : Germany 
8 : Brazil 
7. Yugoslavia
6 :Argentina, Spain  
5 : Holland
4 : France, Soviet Union 
3 : UruguayPortugal, Peru, 
2 : Austria, Czechoslovakia, Romania 
1 : Poland, Hungary, Norway, Chile, Belgium, Scotland, IrelandDenmark, Switzerland, Finland 
____________________________________


The 100 Greatest Defensive and Box-to-Box Midfielders of All-Time

1. Lothar Matthaeus (Germany)
2. Frank Rijkaard (Holland)
3. Jozsef Bozsik (Hungary)
4. Falcao (Brazil)
5. Paul Breitner (Germany)
6. Ernst Ocwirk (Austria)
7. Jose Leandro Andrade (Uruguay)
8. Josef Masopust (Czechoslovakia)
9. Luis Monti (Argentina)
10. Johan Neeskens (Holland)
11. Willem Van Hanegem (Holland)
12. Steven Gerrard (England)
13. Fernando Redondo (Argentina)
14. Obdulio Varela (Uruguay)
15. Igor Netto (Soviet Union)
16. Danny Blanchflower (Northern Ireland)
17. Marco Tardelli (Italy)
18. Jose Pirri (Spain)
19. Bryan Robson (England)
20. Fritz Szepan (Germany)
21. Jean Tigana (France)
22. Patrick Vieira (France)
23. Néstor Rossi (Argentina)
24. Danilo Alvim (Brazil)
25. Edgar Davids (Holland)
26. Roy Keane (Ireland Republic)
27. Osvaldo Ardiles (Argentina)
28. Zito (Brazil)
29. Billy Bremner (Scotland)
30. Toninho Cerezo (Brazil)
31. Graeme Souness (Scotland)
32. Xabi Alonso (Spain)
33. Horst Szymaniak (Germany)
34. Josef Smistik (Austria)
35. Valery Voronin (Soviet Union)
36. Dave Mackay (Scotland)
37. Michael Ballack (Germany) 
38. Zlatko Cajkovski (Yugoslavia)
39. Stefan Effenberg (Germany)
40. Giacomo Bulgarelli (Italy)
41. Uli Stielike (Germany)
42. Duncan Edwards (England)
43. Stefan Bozhkov (Bulgaria)
44. Karel Pesek Kada (Czechoslovakia)
45. Mikael Essien (Ghana)
46. Dino Sani (Brazil)
47. Claude Makelele (France)
48. Manuel Fleitas Solich (Paraguay)
49. Clodoaldo (Brazil)
50. Karl Koller (Austria)
51. Puck Van Heel (Holland)
52. Wilfreid Van Moer (Belgium)
53. Josep Guardiola (Spain)
54. Svatopluk Pluskal (Czechoslovakia)
55. Romeo Benetti (Italy)
56. Andreas Kupfer (Germany)
57. Bauer (Brazil)
58. Wilson Piazza (Brazil)
59. Arie Haan (Holland) 
60. Nils Middelboe (Denmark)
61. Emlyn Hughes (England)
62. Soren Lerby (Denmark)
63. David Meiklejohn (Scotland)
64. Luis Fernandez (France)
64. Jose Velasquez (Peru)
65. John Greig (Scotland)
67. Mauro Silva (Brazil)
68. Antonio Rattín (Argentina)
69. Carlos Dunga (Brazil)
70. Glenn Stromberg (Sweden)
71. Michele Andreolo (Uruguay)
72. Ludwig Goldbrunner (Germany)
73. Javier Mascherano (Argentina)
74. Rainer Bonhof (Germany)
75. Segundo Castillo (Peru)
76. Nestor Goncalves (Uruguay)
77. Ernest Needham (England)
78. Didier Deschamps (France)
79. Olaf Thon (Germany)
80. Esteban Cambiasso (Argentina)
81. Emerson Ferreira (Brazil)
82. Bastian Schweinsteiger (Germany)
83. Carpegiani (Brazil)
84. Alemao (Brazil)
85. Mirolad Arsenijevic (Yugoslavia)
86. Willy Van Der Kerkhof (Holland)
87. Viktor Kolotov (Soviet Union)
88. Walter Nausch (Austria)
89. Laszlo Boloni (Romania)
90. Gennaro Gattuso (Italy)
91. Arturo Vidal (Chile)
92. Bok De Korver (Holland)
93. Paolo Sousa (Portugal)
94. Yaya Toure (Ivory Coast)
95. Renato Zaccarelli (Italy)
96. Americo Gallego (Argentina)
97. Yuri Voinov (Soviet Union)
98. Ante Zanetic (Yugoslavia)
99. Jan Molby (Denmark)
100. Horst Eckel (Germany)

Reserved List

Wim Jansen (Holland)
Gabriel Oriali (Italy)
Sergei Aleinikov (Belarus)
Franky Van Der Elst (Belgium)
Jan Wouters (Holland)
Albin Kitzinger (Germany)
Ciriaco Sforza (Switzerland)
Ron Burgess (Wales)
Jaime Graca (Portugal)
Alex Raisbeck (Scotland)
Diego Simeone (Argentina)
Salvatore Bagni (Italy)
Victor Benitez (Peru)
Demetrio Albertini (Italy)
Ernesto Lazzatti (Argentina)
Eusebio Castigliano (Italy)
Emmanouel Petit (France)
Claudio Marangoni (Argentina)
Victor Munoz (Spain)
Agostino Di Bartolomei (Italy)
Aron Winter (Holland)

Stats By Nation

13 : Brazil, Germany
8 : Holland 
7 : Argentina 
6 : Scotland 
5 : France, England, Italy
4 : Austria, Uruguay, Soviet Union
3 : Spain, Yugoslavia, Czechoslovakia
2 : Peru
1 : Portugal, Hungary, Bulgaria, Ireland Republic, Northern Ireland, 
                     Ghana, Romania, Sweden, Belgium, Ivory Coast, Chile 
____________________________________


The 100 Greatest Wingers of All-Time

1. Garrincha (Brazil)
2. George Best (Northern Ireland)
3. Stanley Matthews (England)
4. Jairzinho (Brazil)
5. Dragan Dzajic (Yugoslavia)
6. Luis Figo (Portugal)
7. Francisco Gento (Spain)
8. Pavel Nedved (Czechoslovakia)
9. Julinho (Brazil)
10. Tom Finney (England)
11. Zoltan Czibor (Hungary)
12. Kurt Hamrin (Sweden)
13. Raimundo Orsi (Argentina)
14. Franck Ribery (France)
15. Arjen Robben (Holland)
16. Pepe (Brazil)
17. Ryan Giggs (Wales) 
18. Jimmy Johnstone (Scotland)
19. Omar Corbatta (Argentina)
20. Piet Keizer (Holland)
21. Carlos Peucelle (Argentina)
22. Felix Loustau (Argentina)
23. Helmut Rahn (Germany)
24. Amanco Amaro (Spain)
25. Hans Schafer (Germany)
26. Grzegorz Lato (Poland)
27. Michel Gonzalez (Spain) 
28. Franco Causio (Italy)   
29. Estanislao Basora (Spain)
30. Bruno Conti (Italy) 
31. Billy Meredith (Wales)
32. Giampiero Boniperti (Italy)
33. Pierre Littbarski (Germany)
34. David Beckham (England)
35. Antonin Puc (Czechoslovakia)
36. Juan Joya (Peru)
37. Canhoteiro (Brazil)         
38. Coen Moulijn (Holland)
39. Alan Morton (Scotland)
40. Karl Aage Praest (Denmark)
41. Lennart Skoglund (Sweden)
42. Bora Kostic (Yugoslavia)
43. Milos Milutinovic (Yugoslavia)
44. Rene Houseman (Argentina)
45. Leonel Sanchez (Chile)
46. Kalman Konrad (Hungary)
47. John Barnes (England)
48. Robert Pires (France)
49. Robert Gadocha (Poland)
50. Gareth Bales (Wales)
51. Enrique Garcia (Argentina)
52. Patsy Gallagher (Northern Ireland)
53. Cliff Bastin (England)
54. Jose Augusto (Portugal)
55. Oscar Mas (Argentina)
56. Paulo Futre (Portugal)
57. Roberto Donadoni (Italy)
58. Brian Laudrup (Denmark)
59. Sjaak Swart (Holland)
60. Marc Overmars (Holland)
61. Cliff Jones (Wales)
62. Alcides Ghiggia (Uruguay)
63. Eder (Brazil)
64. Jurgen Grabowski (Germany)
65. Daniel Bertoni (Argentina)
66. Mario Zagallo (Brazil)
67. Ernest Lehner (Germany)
68. Enrique Hormazabal (Chile)
69. Mario Corso (Italy)
70. Juan Seminario (Peru)
71. Willington Ortiz (Colombia)
72. Johnny Rep (Holland)
73. Cris Waddle (England)
74. David Ginola (France)
75. Eric Brook (England)
76. Augustin Gainza (Spain)
77. Luis Cubilla (Uruguay)
78. Ze Roberto (Brazil)
79. Fernando Chalana (Portugal)
80. Jonas Eduardo Americo (Brazil)
81. Albano Pereira (Portugal)
82. Rogerio Pipi (Portugal)
83. Bobby Lennox (Scotland)
84. Slava Metreveli (Soviet Union)
85. Mikhail Meskhi (Soviet Union)
86. Joel Antonio Martins (Brazil)
87. Isabelino Gradin (Uruguay) 
88. Eberhard Vogel (East Germany)
89. Antonio Simoes (Portugal)
90. Jair Da Costa (Brazil)
91. Eden Hazard (Belgium)
92. Arne Brustad (Norway)
93. Frank Arnsen (Denmark)
94. Igor Chislenko (Soviet Union)
95. Ivan Kolev (Bulgaria) 
96. Billy Liddell (Scotland)
97. Mauro Camoranesi (Italy)
98. Angel Di Maria (Argentina)
99. Alex Jackson (Scotland)
100. Siegfried Held (Germany)


Reserved List

Oscar Gomez Sanchez (Peru)
Sergey Ilyin (Soviet Union)
Luigi Meroni (Italy)
Alex Smith (Scotland)
Roger Magnusson (Sweden)
Vassilis Hatzipanagis (Greece)
Dominique Rocheteau (France)
David Silva (Spain)
Steve Coppell (England)
Davie Cooper (Scotland)
Gino Colaussi (Italy)
Enrique Collar (Spain)
Jean Vincent (France)

Stats By Nations

12 : Brazil 
8 : Argentina, Portugal 
7 : Germany, England
6 : Italy
5 : Scotland 
4 : Spain, Holland, Wales 
3 : France, Yugoslavia, UruguayPeru, Denmark 
2 : Soviet Union, Sweden, Czechoslovakia
PolandHungary, Chile, Northern Ireland 
1 : Colombia, Norway, Belgium
____________________________________


The 100 Greatest Playmakers of All-Time

1. Michel Platini (France)
2. Zinedine Zidane (France)
3. Bobby Charlton (England)
4. Gianni Rivera (Italy)
5. Raymond Kopa (France)
6. Didi (Brazil)
7. Rivelino (Brazil)
8. Michael Laudrup (Denmark)
9. Luis Suarez Miramontes (Spain)
10. Andres Iniesta (Spain)
11. Xavi Hernandez (Spain)
12. Gheorghe Hagi (Romania)
13. Gerhard Hanappi (Austria)
14. Gerson (Brazil)
15. Gunther Netzer (Germany)
16. Wolfgang Overath (Germany)
17. Mario Coluna (Portugal)
18. Socrates (Brazil)
19. Nils Liedholm (Sweden)
20. Kazimierz Deyna (Poland)
21. Juan Roman Riquelme (Argentina)
22. Alain Giresse (France)
23. Ricardo Bochini (Argentina)
24. Bernd Schuster (Germany)
25. Andrea Pirlo (Italy)
26. Frank Lampard (England)
27. Helmut Haller (Germany)   
28. Thomas Haesler (Germany)
29. Clarence Seedorf (Holland)
30. Johnny Giles (Ireland Republic)
31. Rui Costa (Portugal)
32. Herbert Prohaska (Austria)
33. Dragoslav Sekularac (Yugoslavia)
34. Giancarlo Antognoni (Italy) 
35. Safet Susic (Yugoslavia)
36. Glenn Hoddle (England)
37. Cesar Cueto (Peru)
38. Ademir Da Guia (Brazil)
39. Jim Baxter (Scotland)
40. Liam Brady (Ireland Republic)
41. Nicolae Dobrin (Romania)
42. Johnny Haynes (England)
43. Juan Sebastian Veron (Argentina)
44. Paul Scholes (England)
45. Dragan Stojkovic (Yugoslavia)
46. Joseph Jurion (Belgium)
47. Wesley Sneijder (Holland)
48. Ermindo Onega (Argentina)
49. Alex James (Scotland)
50. Jose Travassos (Portugal)
51. Colin Bell (England)
52. Branko Oblak (Yugoslvaia)
53. Paul Gascoigne (England)
54. Bo Larsson (Sweden)
55. Julio Cesar Romero (Paraguay)
56. Josep Samitier (Spain)
57. Enzo Scifo (Belgium)
58. Dirceu Gimaraes (Brazil)
59. Iosif Petschovsky (Romania)
60. Rai (Brazil)
61. Cesc Fabregas (Spain)
62. Deco (Portugal)
63. Lajos Detari (Hungary)
64. Dimitar Yakimov (Bulgaria)
65. Carlos Valderrama (Colombia)
66. Fyordor Cherenkov (Soviet Union)
67. Krassimir Balakov (Bulgaria)
68. Miguel Brindisi (Argentina)
69. Luka Modric (Croatia)
70. David Kipiani (Soviet Union)
71. Dirceu Lopez (Brazil)
72. Kees Rijvers (Holland)
73. Illie Balaci (Romania)
74. Felix Magath (Germany)
75. Antonin Panenka (Czechoslovakia)
76. Zvonimir Boban (Yugoslavia)
77. Leonid Buryak (Soviet Union)
78. Vladimir Muntyan (Soviet Union)
79. Luis Del Sol (Spain)
80. Jurica Jerkovic (Yugoslavia)
81. Humberto Maschio (Argentina)
82. Vladimir Petrovic (Yugoslavia)
83. Gordon Strachan (Scotland)
84. Mehmet Scholl (Germany)
85. Alan Ball (England) 
86. Oleksander Zavarov (Soviet Union)
87. Jorge Burruchaga (Argentina)
88. Asgier Sigurvinsson (Iceland)
89. Julio Cesar Uribe (Peru)
90. Andreas Herzog (Austria)
91. Mezut Ozil (Germany)
92. Mimis Domazos (Greece)
93. Pablo Bengoechea (Uruguay)
94. Gaizka Mendieta (Spain)
95. Jimmy Mcilroy (Northern Ireland)
96. Heinz Flohe (Germany)
97. Francisco Valdes (Chile)
98. Andrej Kvasnak (Czechoslovakia)
99. Robert Prosinecki (Yugoslavia)
100. Lakhdal Belloumi (Algeria)

Reserved List

Alexei Mikhailichenko (Soviet Union)
Rene Petit (France)
Yuri Gavrilov (Soviet Union)
Giorgos Delikaris (Greece)
Rafael Van De Vaart (Holland)
Giuseppe Giannini (Italy)
Marco Etcheverry (Bolivia)
Leonardo (Brazil)


Stats By Nation

10 : Brazil 
9 : Germany
8 : Argentina, EnglandYugoslavia 
7 : Spain 
5 : Soviet Union 
4 : France, Portugal, Scotland, Romania
3 : Italy, AustriaHolland 
2 : Sweden, Belgium, Bulgaria, Ireland Republic, Peru 
1 : Greece, Czechoslovakia, Paraguay, Denmark, Hungary, Chile, Colombia, Northern Ireland, Iceland, Algeria 
____________________________________


The 100 Greatest Trequartistas of All-Time

1. Diego Maradona (Argentina)
2. Johan Cruyff (Holland)
3. Alfredo Di Stefano (Argentina)
4. Zico (Brazil)
5. Jose Manuel Moreno (Argentina)
6. Zizinho (Brazil)
7. Giuseppe Meazza (Italy)
8. Ruud Gullit (Holland)
9. Ronaldinho (Brazil)
10. Roberto Baggio (Italy)
11. Fritz Walter (Germany)
12. Rivaldo (Brazil)
13. Adolfo Pedernera (Argentina)
14. Teofilo Cubillas (Peru)
15. Sandro Mazzola (Italy)
16. Enzo Francescoli (Uruguay)
17. Omar Sivori (Argentina)
18. Hector Scarone (Uruguay)
19. Juan Alberto Schiaffino (Uruguay)
20. Antonio Sastre (Argentina)
21. Nandor Hidegkuti (Hungary)
22. Bernard Vukas (Yugoslavia)
23. Kenny Dalglish (Scotland)
24. Francesco Totti (Italy)
25. Kevin Keegan (England)
26. Zbigniew Boniek (Poland)
27. Valentino Mazzola (Italy)
28. Kaka (Brazil)
29. Jair Da Rosa (Brazil)
30. Rinaldo Martino (Argentina)
31. Pedro Rocha (Uruguay)
32. Stjepan Bobek (Yugoslavia)
33. Ernest Kuzorra (Germany)
34. Gyorgy Orth (Hungary)
35. Dejan Savicevic (Yugoslavia)
36. Jan Ceulemans (Belgium)
37. Larbi Benbarek (France)
38. Allan Simonsen (Denmark)
39. Hristo Bonev (Bulgaria)
40. Valentin Ivanov (Soviet Union)
41. Milan Galic (Yugoslavia)
42. Roger Piantoni (France)
43. Manuel Ferreira (Argentina)
44. Aurelio Gonzalez (Paraguay)
45. Alberto Terry (Peru)
46. Andreas Moller (Germany)
47. Raich Carter (England)
48. Hugo Sotil (Peru)
49. Vaclav Pilat (Czechoslovakia)
50. Bobby Walker (Scotland)
51. Luliu Baratky (Romania)
52. Gunnar Gren (Sweden)
53. Giovanni Ferrari (Italy)
54. Rajko Mitic (Yugoslavia)
55. Karl Decker (Austria) 
56. Friedrich Gschweidl (Austria)
57. Hector Rial (Argentina)
58. Adolfo Baloncieri (Italy)
59. Wilf Mannion (England)
60. Luis Enrique (Spain)
61. Luliu Bodola (Romania)
62. Jari Litmanen (Finland)
63. Gianfranco Zola (Italy)
64. Thomas Muller (Germany)
65. Norberto Mendez (Argentina)
66. Karl Aage Hansen (Denmark)
67. Tibor Nyilasi (Hungary)
68. Angel Romano (Uruguay)
69. Ernesto Grillo (Argentina)
70. Paulo Cesar Lima (Brazil)
71. Anibal Ciocca (Uruguay)
72. Willy Van De Kuijlen (Holland)
73. Edvaldo Dida (Brazil)
74. Abedi Pele (Ghana)
75. Titus Ozon (Romania)
76. Ihor Belanov (Soviet Union)
77. David Platt (England)
78. Osei Kofi (Ghana)
79. Walter Gomez (Uruguay)
80. Hans Jurgen Kreische (East Germany)
81. Vicente De La Mata (Argentina)
82. Roberto Mancini (Italy)
83. Luis De La Fuente (Mexico)
84. Youri Djorkaeff (France)
85. Ivor Allchurch (Wales)
86. Ariel Ortega (Argentina)
87. Martin Peters (England)
88. Henning Jensen (Denmark)
89. Jorge Alberto Gonzalez (El Salvador)
90. Norman Whiteside (Northern Ireland)
91. Roberto Porta (Uruguay)
92. Norberto Alonso (Argentina)
93. Helge Bronee (Denmark)
94. Janos Gorocs (Hungary)
95. Joaquin Peiro (Spain)
96. Peter Palotas (Hungary)
97. Lefter Kucukandonyadis (Turkey)
98. Sergey Salnikov (Soviet Union)
99. Andrei Ashavin (Russia)
100. Tomas Brolin (Sweden) 

Reserved List

Alvaro Recoba (Uruguay)
Mamoud El Khatib (Egypt)
Matthew Le Tissier (England) 
Hallvar Thoresen (Norway)
Djalminha (Brazil)
Pablo Aimar (Argentina)
Hansi Horvath (Austria)
Reidar Kvammen (Norway)
Jurgen Noldner (Germany)


Stats By Nation

13 : Argentina 
9 : Italy 
8 : Brazil
7 : Uruguay 
5 : Hungary, Yugoslavia, Germany
4 : England, Soviet Union, Denmark 
3 : Peru, Holland, France, Romania
2 : Austria, Spain, Sweden, Scotland
1 : Paraguay, Ireland Rep., N.Ireland, Czechoslovakia, Belgium, Turkey, Bulgaria, Mexico
El Salvador, Finland
____________________________________


The 100 Greatest Forwards of All-Time

1. Pele (Brazil)
2. Lionel Messi (Argentina)
3. Cristiano Ronaldo (Portugal)
4. Ferenc Puskas (Hungary)
5. Eusebio (Portugal)
6. Karlheinz Rummenigge (Germany)
7. Matthias Sindelar (Austria)
8. Gyorgi Sarosi (Hungary)
9. Laszlo Kubala (Hungary)
10. Thierry Henry (France)
11. Florian Albert (Hungary)
12. Ademir De Menezes (Brazil)
13. Hristo Stoichkov (Bulgaria)
14. Dennis Bergkamp (Holland)
15. Luis Alberto Suarez (Uruguay)
16. Tostao (Brazil)
17. Leonidas Da Silva (Brazil) 
18. Gyula Zsengeller (Hungary)
19. Oleg Blokhin (Soviet Union)
20. Raul Gonzalez (Spain)
21. Zlaton Ibrahimovic (Sweden)
22. Ferenc Bene (Hungary)
23. Paul Van Himst (Belgium)
24. Angel Labruna (Argentina)
25. Mario Kempes (Argentina)
26. Rob Rensenbrink (Holland)
27. George Weah (Liberia)
28. Oldrich Nejedly (Czechoslovakia)
29. Wlodzimerz Lubanski (Poland)
30. Rene Pontoni (Argentina) 
31. Abe Lenstra (Holland)
32. Servaas Wilkes (Holland)
33. Alessandro Del Piero (Italy)
34. Bebeto (Brazil)
35. Eric Cantona (France)
36. Raymond Braine (Belgium)
37. Anton Schall (Austria)
38. Jose Sanfilippo (Argentina)
39. Ernest Willimowski (Poland)
40. Wayne Rooney (England)
41. David Villa (Spain)
42. Eduard Streltsov (Soviet Union)
43. Manuel Seoane (Argentina)
44. Istvan Nyers (Hungary)
45. Sven Rydell (Sweden)
45. Preben Elkjaer (Denmark)
46. Emilio Butragueno (Spain)
47. Jupp Heynckes (Germany)
48. Henri Coppens (Belgium)
49. Alberto Ohaco (Argentina)
50. Roberto Bettega (Italy)
51. Josip Skoblar (Yugoslavia)
52. Ivan Hitrec (Croatia)
53. Georgi Asparuhov (Bulgaria)
54. Pinga (Portugal)
55. Diego Forlan (Uruguay)
56. Neymar (Brazil)
57. Lajos Tichy (Hungary)
58. Quarentinha (Brazil)
59. Amarildo (Brazil)
60. Robin Van Persie (Holland)
61. Todor Veselinovic (Yugoslavia)
62. John Angelo Hansen (Denmark)
63.  Sergio Aguero (Argentina) 
64. Grigory Fedotov (Soviet Union)
65. Erich Hof (Austria)
66. Kick Smit (Holland)
67. Valstimil Kopecky (Czechoslovakia)
68. Giuseppe Signori (Italy)
69. Agne Somonsson (Sweden)
70. Jose Piendibene (Uruguay)
71. Blagoje Marjanovic (Yugoslavia)
72. Predrag Mijatovic (Yugoslavia)
74. Charlie Buchan (England)
75. Max Morlock (Germany)
76. Geza Toldi (Hungary)
77. Ernest Stojaspal (Austria)
78. Ernest Pohl (Poland)
79. Carlos Tevez (Argentina)
80. Gianluca Vialli (Italy) 
81. Billy Walker (England)
82. Ove Kindvall (Sweden)
83. Klaus Allofs (Germany)
84. Bernard Voorhoof (Belgium)
85. Ruud Geels (Holland)
86. Alejandro Villanueva (Peru)
87. Gerard Cieslik (Poland)
88. Erwin Vandenbergh (Belgium)
89. Laszlo Cesh (Hungary)
90. Severino Verela (Uruguay)
91. Steve Bloomer (England)
92. Stephane Chapuisat (Switzerland) 
93. Roberto Cherro (Argentina)
94. Antonio Angelillo (Argentina)
95. Carlos Caszely (Chile)
96. Josef Hugi (Switzerland)
97. Ruben Sosa (Uruguay)
98. Cha Bum Kun (Korea Republic)
99. Antonio Di Natale (Italy)   
100. Jozef Adamec (Czechoslovakia) 

Reserved List

Raul Toro (Chile)
Nikita Simonyan (Soviet Union)
Salif Keita (Mali)
Florea Dumitrache (Romania) 
Horacio Casarin (Mexico)
Jose Peracio (Brazil)
Pedro Pablo Leon (Peru)
Alejandro Morera (Costa Rica)
Delfin Benitez Caceres (Paraguay)
Carlos Santillana (Spain)
Dragan Jovanovic (Yugoslavia)
David Jack (England)

Stats By Nation

11 : Argentina, 
10 : Hungary 
8 : Brazil 
7 : Holland 
6 : Yugoslavia, Italy
5 : Uruguay, England, Belgium
4 : Germany, Austria, Sweden
3 : Portugal, Spain, Poland, Soviet Union
2 : Peru, Switzerland, France, Bulgaria, Denmark, Czechoslovakia
1 : Korea Republic, Liberia, Chile
____________________________________

The 100 Greatest Target Strikers of All-Time

1. Ronaldo (Brazil)
2. Gerd Muller (Germany)
3. Marco Van Basten (Holland)
4. Romario (Brazil)
5. Sandor Kocsis (Hungary)
6. Uwe Seeler (Germany)
7. Gunnar Nordahl (Sweden)
8. Josef Bican (Austria)
9. Dixie Dean (England)
10. Jimmy Greaves (England)
11. Gabriel Batistuta (Argentina)
12. Silvio Piola (Italy)
13. Luigi Riva (Italy)
14. Andriy Shevchenko (Ukraine)
15. Arsenio Erico (Paraguay)
16. Jurgen Klinsmann (Germany)
17. John Charles (Wales)
18. Ruud Van Nistelrooy (Holland)
19. Imre Schlosser (Hungary)
20. Telmo Zarra (Spain)
21. Jean Pierre Papin (France)
22. Denis Law (Scoland)
23. Hugo Sanchez (Mexico)
24. Jozsef Takacs (Hungary)
25. Just Fontaine (France)
26. Arthur Friedenreich (Brazil)
27. Luis Artime (Argentina)
28. Rudi Voller (Germany)
29. Jimmy Mcgrory (Scotland)
30. Gary Lineker (England)
31. Samuel Eto'o (Cameroon)
32. Nat Lofthouse (England)
33. Didier Drogba (Ivory Coast)
34. Careca (Brazil)
35. Fernando Peyroteo (Portugal)
36. Ferenc Deak (Hungary)
37. Jose Altafini (Brazil)
38. Christian Vieri (Italy)
39. Alan Shearer (England)
40. Franz Binder (Austria)
41. Pedro Petrone (Uruguay)
42. Heleno De Freitas (Brazil) 
43. Isidro Langara (Spain)
44. Alberto Spencer (Ecuador)
45. Ian Rush (Wales)
46. Michael Owen (England)
47. Alfred Schaffer (Hungary)
48. David Trezeguet (France)
49. Teodoro Fernandez (Peru)
50. Valeriano Lopez (Peru)
51. Hernan Crespo (Argentina)
52. Tommy Lawton (England)
53. Paolo Rossi (Italy)
54. Davor Suker (Croatia)
55. Hans Krankl (Austria)
56. Vava (Brazil)
57. Lucas Matateu (Portugal) 
58. Fernando Morena (Uruguay)
59. Richard Hofmann (Germany)
60. Joseph Mermans (Belgium)
61. Reinaldo (Brazil)
62. Oscar Miguez (Uruguay)
63. Herminio Masantonio (Argentina)
64. Hughie Gallacher (Scotland)
65. Stan Mortensen (England)
66. Darko Pancev (Yugoslavia)
67. Atilio Garcia (Uruguay)
68. Robert Dienst (Austria)
69. Ferenc Szusza (Hungary)
70. Patrick Kluivert (Holland)
71. Roberto Dinamite (Brazil)
72. Beb Bakhuys (Holland)
73. Thadee Cisowski (France)
74. Jose Aguas (Portugal)
75. Istvan Avar (Hungary)
76. Henrik Larsson (Sweden)
77. Jackie Milburn (England)
78. Pauli Jorgensen (Denmark)
79. Dimitar Berbatov (Bulgaria)
80. Oliver Bierhoff (Germany)
81. Klaus Fischer (Germany)
82. Dusan Bajevic (Yugoslavia)
83. Joachim Streich (East Germany)
84. Filippo Inzaghi (Italy)
85. Miroslav Klose (Germany)
86. Robert Lewandowki(Poland)
87. Bernabe Ferreyra (Argentina) 
88. Countinho (Brazil)
89. Albert De Cleyn (Belgium)
90. Toni Polster (Austria)
91. Marcelo Salas (Chile)
92. Luca Toni (Italy)
93. Carlos Bianchi (Argentina)
94. Giovanne Elber (Brazil)
95. Roberto Boninsegna (Italy)
96. Domingo Tarasconi (Argentina)
97. Oleg Protasov (Soviet Union)
98. Angelo Schiavio (Italy)
99. Robert Hamilton (Scotland)
100. Fernando Torres (Spain)

Reserved List

George Camsell (England)
Radamel Falcao (Colombia)
Zeki Riza Sporel (Turkey)
Metin Oktay (Turkey)
Adriano (Brazil)
Francisco Varallo (Argentina)
Roger Hunt (England)
Petar Zhekov (Bulgaria)
Andre Abegglen (Switzerland)
Gyula Szilagyi (Hungary)
Franz Weselik (Austria)
Coen Dillen (Holland)
Edmundo Suarez (Spain)


Stats By Nations

12 : Brazil 
9 : Germany
8 : England 
7 : Argentina, Hungary 
7 : Italy 
5 : Austria, Holland, Uruguay 
4 : France
3 : Scotland, Portugal, Spain, Yugsolavia 
2 : Soviet Union,Belgium, Sweden, Peru, Wales 
1 : Bulgaria, Mexico, Denmark, Chile, Paraguay, Ecuador, Cameroon, Ivory Coast, Poland
____________________________________


All Statistics 

By Nations 

Brazil  100
Germany  81
Argentina 75
Italy  70
England  62
Yugoslavia  44
Holland  41
Scandinavia  40    
France  37
Spain  36
Uruguay  34
Hungary  33
Soviet Union  29
Portugal  27
Austria  23
Sweden  22
Scotland 21
Belgium  21
Peru  18
Czechoslovakia  14
Denmark  13
Romania  11
Chile  11

By Zone/Continent

Rest of Central Europe 77       
Iberia 65
Balkan 65
Rest of UK and Ireland 43
Rest of Latin Americas 38
Scandinavia 39    
Africa 8
Asia 1

283 comments:

  1. I don't think Sergio Goycochea deserves it. He may have been good at a world cup but he was never close to a top class keeper in his general career. A good prime performance is nothing if you are not close to be world class in general. For example he in nowhere near Julio Cesar in career performance. Cesar was one of the best keepers in the world for a number of seasons but he is only a few places ahead of Goycochea. Based on total career even recent keepers like Handanovic or Caballero would already be ahead of Goycochea since they have actually been world class at club level. I would also argue Carbajal is too high. What is longevity if you were never a high class keeper. Was he ever considered a top class keeper in his day?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have long realized about it. Goycochea has been rated in the top 100 because his higher peak performance in World stage. I try to include all players who ever reach World-Class. In the substitution list, most of them were low profile in NT career and not have a World-Class rating except Fritz Henkenrath who kicker rated in world-class but I see standard of kicker rating at that time gave high-class to more players than later era although German players in 1950s wasn't its golden era.

      Antonio Carbajal is always debatable. The fact that Mexico in his era was much inferior to the majority of teams in World Cup, he conceded many goals, is easy to conclude that Catbajal is kacl of international success. He also played the whole career in Mexican League which was below international average in competitive standard. Carbajal conceded fewest goals in the league in just twice seasons and second fewest in four seasons and third fewest in 2 seasons. This stats could not tell us about his individual performance but at least it shows status of Carbajal that he is not too far dominate the league. I agree to rank him lower.

      Delete
    2. where's vitor damas? he was just as good as bento

      Delete
    3. Vitor Damas, is regarded by most Portuguese as one of their best keepers ever but at his only 28 years old when the most goalkeepers was spending their prime, he already completely lost first choice to Manuel Bento in Portugal national team and even before 29 years old, he was not a regular starter in some years, totally Damas was capped only 29 games. Look into his club career, I see he has prime career at Sporting Portugal but when he moved to Racing Santander, his career seems to start falling down. Anyway, he is actually named in honorable mention.

      Delete
    4. what about costa rica's luis gabelo conejo? he is a criminally under-appreciated player goalkeeper and agreed costa rica weren't that good yet his performance was just fabulous in 1990 world cup. also he along with goycochea was included as the goalkeeper of the tournament.

      Delete
    5. Conejo is famous for his great saves in the 1990 World Cup. Aside from that tournament, there is no evidence to prove he is great in club career. He played in second division with Albacete at the first season and helped the team to promote and in the next season Albacete finished 7th place in La Liga but not sure why he returned to his homeland too early. He mainly played in Costa Rican league.

      Delete
    6. well he was great enough to be in a top club. it's just his agent duped him to go to such a club like albacete. if not for his agent he could've had a fabulous club career since he got offers from clubs like torino,espanyol as such

      Delete
  2. David Silva should be listed as a AMF. He is not a traditional winger. I also think he should be ranked higher.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, but he is closest to be called as "Semi-Side Midfielder" and I've seen him ,much more effective is semi-side area than just base on central area. Probably, he could be in top 100 when next seasons will have been finished.

      Delete
    2. An number of players listed in your AMF listed would have also played wide in a 4-4-2 as playmaker type player.

      Delete
    3. You means AM list in ten or seven categories ? For this list (ten category), Haesler and Iniesta are the two obvious examples to be categorized as semi-side midfielder and they're finally named in playmaker because they're seen to be a better performer in central area than the side area. David Silva always operated the game in the tree-quarter line in the semi-side area, is distinguish from players in AM list who are often base on central midfield area to create the game.

      Delete
  3. I think Thomas Muller is too high. Notwithstanding his surprisingly good world cup performance, he only has one season where he might be considered world class. If you compared between 100 list, it would appear that player like David Silva or Schweinsteiger are less great, which makes little sense based on cumulative career., whilst player like Ozil aren't even ranked.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. T. Muller is much better than Schweintseinger and Ozil in Two World Cup. I'd say full one world-class is enough for 70th easily in ranking standard of performance profile.
      Note : Schweinsteinger is just surprised when Kicker rank him below international-class in all seasons before 2010.

      Delete
    2. Better in the world cup but worse in general career(as far im concerned). I think latter trumps.

      Delete
    3. I think Schweinsteiger's kicker is underrated. He's been very good since he became a CM. In the last 4 years, Schweinsteger and Silva have had considerably better club careers. While world cup is important, I find it to be far less important than club career since it only 7 games per world cup. I find people tend to overrate players based on world cup performances. Its not as if Muller was remarkably good at 2014 fifa world cup.

      Delete
    4. Do you have your own proportional criteria of international level ? When World Cup has been held just for a few games, it is undeniably the biggest stage legend should achieve the high individual performance. Personally, I'm not much impressive on Thomas Muller who is seen too slow and lack of special technique but the names below him are also inconsistency.

      Delete
    5. The names below are inconsistent but they have played full careers. Their cumulative performance would certainly be higher.

      Delete
    6. What about Altobelli?

      Delete
    7. What about Mario Gomez?

      Delete
    8. Altobelli was too inconsistency as I checked, just has a great 3 -4 seasons.
      Mario Gomez is another striker to ever achieve world-class but he has only 3.5 great seasons (calculate of ration between games played and total games). His NT career is considered to fail because he could not even win the position from the much older Klose.

      Delete
    9. It may have been disappointing that Gomez was unable to win a place from the much inferior Klose, but it hardly disappointing when you take into account Klose's remarkable overachiever at international level.

      Delete
    10. I'd also say Gomez has achieved more than 3.5 great seasons.

      Delete
  4. Marcelo Salas I don't think should be ranked. His career is very average. He only has two seasons of note and these are still only 12 and 15 goals which is unremarkable for a striker of his style of play. He is very talented and has a decent international record, but imagine how many game he would play internationally if he was Argentinian or Italian. If we picked players who had good international and club careers why not pick Huntelaar. His international record is better as is his club career. I don't actually think Huntelaar should be there but hes just an example.

    Salas' cumulative performance is far far inferior to unranked player like Luca Toni or Diego Milito. These player have better primes and have far more good seasons. There or more players who have considerably better careers. For example Mario Gomez, Roy Makaay, Alessandro Altobelli, Adriano Leite Ribeiro(don't think he should be ranked but he has abetter prime) etc. I know Makaay has a poor international record but his club career is far better. Imagine if Salas were Dutch, how would he fair competing with Kluivert and Nistelrooy whilst scoring moderate numbers for Universidad de Chile and River Plate and being injured/out of form at Juventus.

    Anyway the lists are very good. Regards.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Salas is well-known as an inconsistency player but his peak is seen to be a spectacular and all-round striker. His style of goalscoring was always entertained to watch, volley the long ball, great jumping and heading and considerable technique. He is believed to achieve World-Class in his peak performance in 1997 and his NT career is very great.

      For Adriano, He is also a world-class striker in 2003 - 2004 season and record in NT career is better than the likes of Elber, Bianchi, etc but he was too short in maintaining state of top players. I agree to name him in substitution.

      Delete
    2. What about Luca Toni and Diego Milito?

      As for Salas, the fact that he has good ability, as far as im concerned in no way justifies his place. His career is many magnitudes worse than those around him. You say he is world class in 1997 but he only scored 11 in 26 in the league which really average. Does Toni not get world class for scoring 31 league goals(and the many other good seasons) or Milito get it for scoring 24 league goals and being one of the best champions league? I hardly think Salas's reputation as a "spectacular and all-round striker" is any reason to rank him. While I'd say he reached world class ability, I would say that none of his seasons reached close to world class performance(particularily in the league). Do you really think he prime seasons are anywhere near as good as Luca Toni, Diego Milito, Adriano Leite Ribeiro and Roy Makaay?

      Regards

      Delete
    3. I referred to his calendar entire season in 1997 includes international competition. Salas totally had a poor career in Series A, just one great season at Lazio in his first year. He might be concluded roughly to achieve only 3 international-class in club competition. He is no doubt disqualified to be listed in club part. Internationally, Salas' peak helped River Plate to achieve the 1998 Copa Libertadores Cup semi-finalist and he was believed to reach world-class with Chilea in 1997 and 1998.

      I agree Luca toni was a world-class striker in the 2005 - 2006 season. I still rate him slightly below Salas for international favor. Milito is too poor in NT part, would be out of scope. If players were too failure in international stage, it is very disadvantageous and my criteria is set to exclude them likes the case of Roy Makaay. But still, I admit to really overrate Salas and would rank down.

      Your suggestion is often a good point and I think the list will have been much improved from your notice. Please continue if you see some unreasonable point.

      Delete
    4. Surely Diego Milito would be counted as world class in the 2009-10 season. Even if he was good in all competitions in 1997, his performance in the league mean he is nowhere near world class in my books. I personally wouldn't have him anywhere near the top 100. I'd probably even select Luis Fabiano ahead of him.

      In terms of international career, I sometimes don't mind if these players don't have much of an international career. Makaay and Milito had much better players to compete with. If Salas had been from thgose nationalities, he would have likely failed too. Even if you do a 60:40 proportion for club career to international career(which I think is too high) I would still rank Makaay and Milito ahead because their club career are much better. Even if I agreed with you that Salas was world class in 1997, the rest of his career would make it that I would not rank him in the top 100.

      Regards

      Delete
    5. What is your opinion in terms of ranking on the following players:

      Delio Onnis
      Jardel
      Carlos Tevez
      Gareth Bale
      Antonio Cassano

      Antonio Cassano was certainly world class for one season at Sampdoria

      Delete
    6. Only Bales and Cassano from your list achieved at least a world-class season but the rest of career saw too out of standard for Cassano and Bales is needed to collect more performance amount. Onnis and Jardel is absolutely impressive scorer but almost all of them were made against national level defenders and both are also lack of international success. Tevez was only great in his early career. If we consider his advanced role, it is very disappointing for his scoring results and he was too ineffective in NT career.

      Delete
    7. I don't personally think Onnis or Jardel should be in the top 100. However in reference to you saying they scored against national level defenders, the same is true with Salas for most of his career, albeit less prolific and in arguably in easier leagues(Chile and Argentina) to score in.

      Delete
    8. How was Carlos Tevez's best career in the early part of his career. His top season have been at Man City, Juventus and Man U.

      Delete
    9. Sorry I incorrectly definite my word "Early". I actually did mean to include his great Man City season. Tevez is believed to achieve world-class in a short peak during that season but his NT is out of lower limited criteria.

      Delete
  5. Darco Pancev is too high. His Yugoslav record is pretty good but the rest of his career is non existent. He must be this high because he placed on the Ballon d'Or but these things are often overly biased to the European cup.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pancev was a prolific scorer in Yugoslav league in three seasons. I think his scoring style is impressive and number of scoring in high standard competition like Yugoslav league is enough to rate him in World-Class in any season. When consider his impact on Europea Cup in 1991, I think it even likely to underrate him.

      Delete
  6. What about Arturo Vidal?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As I check in media rating, he was below the range of players' grouping standard.

      Delete
  7. I think Luis Suarez is too high. He wasn't world class, bar his to last 2 seasons at Liverpool.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. He should be world-class if consider his incredible influence to Liverpool. He is a footballer who could change the game result by himself and very consistency to rely on his dangerous ball conduction in the front line. Suarez has been successful in NT career also.

      Delete
  8. What about Alexander Mostovoi?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. He is seen to be a high quality playmaker on the pitch for his great impact to the small clubs in domestic competition but was not raised his career status to international success, is generally not regarded as one of the best playmakers in his generation.

      Delete
  9. Roger Milla should not be here. I know he is influential, but he was never anywhere near a top class player during his career, both internationally and at club level. I don't think off-field influence(being important for African football) is important when ranking players but evn if you took it into account, he would still not be anywhere near the top 100. Many African players who would never be ranked in these lists are far greater players than Milla. For example Kanoute, Yeboah etc.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Where have you seen Milla here ? I ever named him in this list but have removed for a long time.

      Delete
    2. My bad, I was thinking of the top 50 African players list

      Delete
  10. I believe Paul Scholes is rated too lowly. He has been widely praised by his peers and opposing managers as the best midfielder of his era. An era including Xavi Iniesta and Pirlo.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Where do you think Scholes should be placed at least ?

      Delete
  11. Replies
    1. Please specify the names should not be ranked ahead of him and give a reason.

      Delete
  12. where is Sergio Ramos? Puyol 77! He must be better

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sergio Ramos is a good defender but has not been considered as one of the very best defenders in the World base on individual quality.

      Puyol is a great physical and uncompromising defender, was shining in the late 2000s as the era of least competitiveness in defending position. I'm sure if he born in the 1980s, he would be regarded much lower.

      Delete
    2. Last few years Sergio Ramos is best defender in the world without competition!

      Delete
  13. Suarez and Rivera better then Laudrup? Rivaldo and Gullit better then Ronaldinho? No chanche!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Both has much longer prime than elder Laudrup. The same reason to Rivaldo and Gullit VS Ronaldinho. However, in another list of highest peak performer, both M.Laudrup and Ronaldinho are rated higher.

      Delete
  14. Good evening! I follow this site and I am very pleased with what I see. However, I would suggest a couple of things to change or consideration. GOALKEEPER: I think it would Ferenc Plattko had to be there, CENTRAL DEFENDER: Josef Blum, Miodrag Belodedici, Glenn Hysen, Ivica Horvat, Bernardo Miguel Thorbjorn Svenssen, Costica Stefanescu, SIDE BACK: Sergio Ramos (I can not believe that it is not there), Sinisa Mihajlovic (compete for position), Robert Jarni- late 90's, one of the best left-Beck. DEFANSIVE MIDFIELD - Sune Andersson (great player), Chinesinho and Fausto (forgotten Brazilians), Luka Modric and Yaya Toure (from the present day), Francisco Olazar WINGER: Roald Jensen (small club, but a great player), Jimmy Quinn, Jan Studnicka (one of the best in his time), Jesper Olsen (short career but top 3-4 years, although in Bordeaux has played side back, Frank Arnesen (many agree the biggest talent in Denmark ever), Alexander Tirnanic.TREQUARTISTA and FORWARD : both Abegglen, Tom Lund, Marcel Raducanu (great player), Kristen Nygaard (by voetbal 1999, among the top 100 of all time), Joseph Ujlaki, Gerard Wodarz, Mark Wilmots (Great sporty character), Ralf Edstrom, Fran Matosic (729 goals ), Josef Silny, Jorge L. Sorensen, Fran Wolfl-, Jose Manuel Pepe- (tragic death), Ruben Paz. I forgot Playmaker: Vlastimil Kopecky above all, lucid and brilliant, Lubo Moravcik, Abderrahman Mahjoub, Luis Regueiro

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks you for your following. Sergio Ramos is overrated. He is a great team-work player and impressive athletic spirit but his defensive quality could be seen in many other players. Media rating support my opinion also as he is rated very low. As your suggestion, they’ all are one of legends of their country but not among the best in their own era except Belodedicci who was indispensable player to help Steua and Red Star won European Cup. Glenn Hysen, As I check he is rated in only 6.23 and 6.03 during twice seasons at Fiorentina, that is average for standard of defender in Series A during that era. Ivan Horvat is another great defender but I never found or heard he is that great. Articles also not describe him in special characteristic.

      Delete
  15. STRIKER: Pichichi, Alcantara, Harald Nielsen, Gunnar Andersson, Tommy Taylor, Poul Tist Nielsen (big striker), Slaven Zambata, Nehoda. Goodbye!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Side-back: Jarni in his time meant more than Branco. Career Mihajlovic and Sorin is incomparable. It's not clear how Sorin found that high. Howard Spencer must be included because it is represented in his time. Central defender: Aldair, Buchwald, Collovati and Khidiatullin are good defenders, but Hysen, Svenssen, Stefanescu and Migueli certainly represent more. Central Midfielder: Is Wilson Piazza, Essien, Emerson and Franky Van der Elst can mean more than Yaya Toure, Modric, Sune Andersson and Francisco Olazar? Among playmaker happen strangest things. Dragan Stojkovic ?? Exceptionally talented. He failed in Verona and Olimpique. Two or three years in the Red Star I think it is not enough for such a high ranking. Two Yugoslav championship! Detari- even less sense there. What are the career had Belloumi, Mendieta and Uribe? Dirceu Lopes ???? Rai, Kipiani I Zavarov are too short. There are level with those listed Moravcik and Mahjoub and Regueiro. Vlastimil Kopecky is better than all. Wingers: Now, by what criteria Fernando Chalana can be better than Jesper Olsen? Ze Roberto ?? Ginola was great potential. Unfortunately, it was before playboy than a footballer. Jan Studnicka was a giant of his time. Frank Arnesen was large and unhappy player. Games at Ajax and Denmark national team, I think it has secured the status of legend.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Modric would fir to playmaker in this list. Yaya Toure is debatable, probably I will name him at the end of this season. I name Olazar in World XI in 1910s but the era was not much competitive so his real ability is questionable.

      Fernando Chalana's peak is exceptional as one of the most talent Portuguese wingers ever, he was named in top five Ballon'Dor once in 1984 arguably achieved world-class season. Ze Roberto is very impressive for his entertaining dribble and efficient crossing but he was never rated as one of the best wingers in the world.

      Delete
    2. Stojkovic was a world-class player in Yugoslav league at least twice seasons, is enough to be named in honorable mention.

      Delete
    3. According to France Football, Jesper Olsen was two years the top ranked player of the Dutch league. One can not say that this league was worse than the Yugoslav. Chalana is better than Olsen because of his talent ??? Unfortunately, there is no reason that Fernando is better. They are very similar players. Chalan remains most remembered for games at Euro 84. He was 25 years old. After that played nothing.

      Delete
    4. I positive that Yugoslav league is more competitive than Dutch league by a mile in the entire league not only the top teams. Jesper Olsen finished second place Dutch footballer in the first season at Ajax and third place in his second season and the last season saw his injury and played around half of total games. In 1983 he was voted in eighth place BallonD’or. However, he had only twice good seasons with Man Utd and was never named in PFA team of the year in any season. Anyway, I agree Chalana is overrated because he also has very short prime due to injury.

      Delete
    5. Jesper Olsen was second in the competition: Lerby, Molby, Rijkaard, Gullit, Van Basten, R.Koeman, Thioresen, Willy Van de Kerkhoff, Van Breukelen and Wouters. I cite only the players that you mentioned on the lists. Cruyff, Van Hanegem and Geels are also played. But they were already older. Dragan Stojkovic had his best season 88/89. In competition with him were still on your list: Savicevic, Pančev, Suker and Prosinecki. A year later and Boban. Do I need to list who's Jesper Olsen was a competition in England. Even I agree that Stojkovic was greater potential of Jesper Olsen. Career is however on the side of Jesper Olsen. A comparison of Fernando Chalana and Jesper Olsen does not have nothing to say.

      Delete
    6. Jesper Olsen is better in: attack, defance, balance, stamina, top speed, response, acceleration,agility, shot technique, shot power, shot accuracy, header, free kick, jump, aggression, mentality and team work. Chalana was better in technique, long pass, and dribble. In short pass is same. Although similar in all fields.Jesper Olsen had a successful club and national career. Stojkovic is as Pančev lost when he left Yugoslavia.

      Delete
  17. We all know the qualities that had Magico. Is that enough? The highlight of his career was playing in Cadiz. Osei Kofi has something similar. Luis Enrique is my tastes also placed too high. David Platt same. Norman Whiteside? This is probably collapsed before his 22 year. Recoba also remains on talent. Brolin was promised a lot. Injuries have taken their toll. In England it was included in the 11 worst arrivals in the premier league. Ruben Paz Ujlaki, Kristen Nygaard and Marcel Raducanu above all, deserve at least to be another consideration. Tom Lund was a great player. He never left Norway. Real Madrid wanted him. Caszely Hugi and Salif Keita are questionable when you compare them with JLSorensen, Matosic and Silny. Jose Manuel Pepe died young. And finally, Strikers: Darko Pančev ????? Who is Darko Pančev? With 25 years no one has heard of him! He played in a strong Red Star a couple of years. He received the ball Savičević, Prosinecki and Stojkovic. He was a good shooter, but certainly was not good enough to get among the best. Vieri is too high for my taste. Berbatov, Salas and Torres are very questionable. Bierhoff and Toni Polster does not deserve to be among the best. And when I saw that there Inzaghi and I could not believe. Inzaghi front Poul Nielsen or Gunnar Andersson, and Harald Nielsen (the most expensive transfer of all time then). Paulino Alcantara same.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Paulinho Alcantara played in Catalan amateur league against teams in a level of second or even lower divisions in nowadays.

      I had a wrong NT goal record of Magico Gonzalez but now I agree he is overrated and should be ranked down.

      Franes Matosic scored only 6 goals in 16 games in the war-time when most top strikers scored a ton of goals.

      Delete
    2. Of course it is played in Catalonia. Spanish League was founded when he was 33 years old. Cups existed. So that's won five Cups. Barcelona's players did not have priority in the national team. Francis Matosic amassed 16 only gets to Yugoslavia in a very strong competition. Do not forget that it is in the best years and grabbed world war II (5-6 years). Pančev amassed 27 in times when the matches were played more often, and had no competition in the attack as Matosic. Pančev his entire career in the national team was a minor character in relation to Zlatko Vujovic. Only after Italia 90 becomes the first attacker. And it takes one year.

      Delete
    3. In those 16 games, Yugoslavia has reached 24 goals. Every fourth means by Matošić. For that Yugoslavia were then nasupali Mitic, Bobek, Vukas ..... (after world war II)

      Delete
  18. Poul Nielsen was one of the greatest players of his time, and now it has surpassed Pippo Inzaghi. Ha-ha! I think you neglect these old footballers. Until 1930 England and Scotland were of course number one. Argentina and Uruguay were the dominant outside Europe. However, Cheska, Hungary, Denmark and Austria also had a strong league and great players.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You need to check it. Poul Tist Nielsen played in danish third division in his whole club career. He scored a large number in international career against a very low standard amateur team like Norway. Football in that era was not much competitive and most international games are friendly matches in their zone, it would be simply that a few players in early era are named in the list.

      Delete
    2. National Football Tournament (1913-1927)
      Year Winner (titles) [13] Runners-up [13]
      1912-13 KB (1) B 1901
      1913-14 KB (2) B 93
      1914-15 No competition held due to World War I
      1915-16 B 93 (1) KB
      1916-17 KB (3) AB
      1917-18 KB (4) Randers Freja
      1918-19 AB (1) B 1901
      1919-20 B 1903 (1) B 1901
      1920-21 AB (2) AGF
      1921-22 KB (5) B 1901
      1922-23 Frem (1) AGF
      1923-24 B 1903 (2) B 1913
      1924-25 KB (6) AGF
      1925-26 B 1903 (3) B 1901
      1926-27 B 93 (2) Skovshoved

      For those Poul Nielsen writes that he played for the KB (1907-1927), he was a champion of Denmark six times. Danes are generally played at the time with Sweden and Norway. Sweden Nielsen scored 15 goals, Norway 23. In one match with Germany by all 4 goals to win 4-1. In one game against the Netherlands scored three goals in the victory of 4-3. He scored and England and Belgium. Cheskoslovakia remains the only national team against whom he played and not scored. He played against them two times. Although it had already 30

      Delete
    3. And one more thing. At the time when Poul Nielsen played, not many national teams in Europe was stronger than Norway. England, Scotland, Denmark, Sweden, Netherlands, Belgium, Italy, Czech Republic, Austria, Hungary and Spain. I'm not sure that it was Germany. France was not, that's for sure. East Europe has not been nearly as competitive.

      Delete
  19. Tommy Taylor was killed in a plane crash 1958. 166 matches and 112 goals for Manchester United. 19 appearances and 16 goals for England national team. Is Darko Pančev better than him or by Harald Nielsen?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pancev played in Yugoslav league with very high standard at that time and he was a prolific scorer and he has much longer career than Tommy Taylor. I did not name Harald Nielsen in the list ? his inconsistency profile is very similar to Tommy Taylor.

      Delete
    2. Pančev fact, already in 1991 the barn with serious football. 1992 has already played in the crumbling league. He failed at Inter, Leipzig, and Fortune. Tommy Taylor has died at the age of 26 .Statistika already mentioned. Harald Nielsen is two times was the top scorer of the Italian League and with Atalanta. You must agree to the Italian league was much stronger at the time of Yugoslavia. Nielsen played against a much stronger defensive players. A Pančev played in Red Star, which in those years, the sovereign dominated Yugoslavia. When he went away to Europe collapsed.

      Delete
    3. In qualifying for Italia 90, Pančev did not play a single minute. At the World Cup he played one match and one entered as a reserve.

      Delete
    4. His international career is short but still made 0.63 goal ratio, is one of highest in his era. In 1991, Pancev was not only a top scorer in Yugoslavian league but also was the all-time highest scorer in a single Yugoslav season and importantly was highest scorer among league around the world.

      Delete
    5. Not to some reasons. Pančev was top scorer and 90/91 with 34 goals. Yugoslav league then counted the largest number of clubs. Take, for example Romania. Dudu Georgescu is in season 76/77 scoring 47 goals. Rodion Camataru in season 86/87 scored 44 goals. Dorin Mateut in season 88/89 scored 43 goals. Darko Pančev is for the national team scoring 17 goals. 4 goals scored in friendlies Austria, Finland and Greece. 11 goals scored in qualifying matches. 4 Goals Northern Ireland, Austria 3 goals, 2 goals Faroe Islands, Cyprus 1 goal, and one goal Denmark (strongest team which Pančev the score). 2 goals scored in the championships. It happened in 1990 when the United Arab Emirates scored 2 goals. Darko Pančev does not deserve to be among the 200 best strikers. Al these are your website

      Delete
  20. As to the journalists' score, specify just one example. In Spain in season 92/93 best foreign-rated player was Miroslav Djukic !!. The best Spanish player in the same season was Fran Gonzalez. A year ago it was Agustin Elduayen. Is really think that this year Djukic played better than Stoichkov, Laudrup, Bebeto .... Or that Spain did not have a better player than Gonzalez and Elduayen who have gathered together 16 appearances for the national team.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The rating can be analyzed for its biased and perspective. Several times less famous players are rated higher than superstar when the rater emphasize the effectiveness of playing and take minor part in level of playing characteristic. Thereby it is still good to apply it properly. At least it is still useful to check season by season in each player to get the profile of performance.

      Delete
    2. I would really like to ask you to respond to the above what about Inzaghi, Whiteside, Stojkovic, Sorin, Belloumi, Khidiatullin, Piazza, Van der Elst, Uribe, Dirceu Lopes, Fernando Chalana, Ze Roberto, Kofi, Recoba, Bierhoff Polster. .... about my alternatives? Respect!

      Delete
    3. Mihajlovic, not mention his free-kick ability, was average defender in series A at that time with low speed and made too many unessential fouls. Sorin was a dynamic and energetic wing-back and dominated the game in the left-side. Jarni is a very fast left-side player but I saw he was not much contribute to his team because of his limited defensive and team work ability.

      Sune Andersson was injury too long as I remmeber.
      Dirceu Lopez : If you know how much has Ademir Da Guia underrated, Dirceu Lopez was selected more times in Brazilian League team of the season. When player won few caps because of the coincidence of another or other world-class players, they would not be fully punished.

      Norman Whiteside, likes you said his career was ended too early but also thanks to his shine start at very young age, is one of the youngest international players in Europe with only 17 years and 41 days. He totally had six great seasons.

      Delete
  21. Impatiently I expect answers to all my questions. I send a lot of greetings and respect!

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thanks for Belodedici !

    ReplyDelete
  23. My friend, you have not offered any answers. You gave me a real argument for Fernando Chalana, Darko Pančev, Kofi, Belloumi, Piazza, Van der Elst, Uribe, Polster, Inzaghi, Bierhoff Polster ...... You did not answer any of my new writing about Alcantara, Poul Nielsen , Matosic. You have not written anything about Arnesen, Kopecky, Raducanu .......... Some things are not very convincing for Sorin, Whiteside, Stojkovic. What's on Keita, Aldair, Gunnar Andersson, Nehoda Mahjoub, Regueiro Silny, Studnicka, Quinn, Nygaard, Stefanescu ...... You are not able to convince me that Pančev made more than Harald Nielsen and Tommy Taylor. There are a list of the best players. Yours are the best. Maybe that's why I like drudgery. But on all these lists know how to find Harald Nielsen and Taylor. Nowhere and never I have not found Pančev! Sorry for my English!

    ReplyDelete
  24. I'm just reply other reasons of Pancev rating as above. Your new comment on Alcantara, Poul Nilsen and Matosic is another positive view ิีbut still not wipe out what I have issued the most important points for them. Arnesen, as I check he is not rated in the top rank in any season during his career at Spain and Belgium. I do not find any strong evidence to believe Kopecky, Raducanu, Stefanescu, Stidnicka was that great (honesty I just ever heard of them slightly)

    ReplyDelete
  25. Arnesen has played in Španjolskij only one season 81/82. Before the start of the second season he broke his leg. In the season 82/83 has not played a single game. Arnesen was brilliant at Ajax and the national team. It was good that season 81/82 in Spain. He was good and in Anderlecht and Eindhoven. The last round of the Dutch Championship 87/88 again broke his leg and did not play the Champions League final against Benfica.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Sergio Ramos is 28 years old. He played 122 matches for the national team the strongest it has ever been. He was selected as the best defensive player in the Spanish league three times (2012,2013,2014). FIFA / FIFPro World XI elected him four times in the best team of the year (2008,2011,2012,2013). UEFA elected him three times (2008,2012,2013). It is likely that 2014 ESM Team of the Year: 2007-08, 2011-12. It will probably be 2014 .. FIFA World Cup Dream Team: 2010..UEFA Euro Team of the Tournament: 2012 .. I think that's enough to be among the top 50. In defensive game was certainly better than Antonio Cabrini

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. International Appearances represent consistency of player but cannot confirm players performance level depend on how great of candidate. Competitiveness of Spain's defensive player is very low but I agree i may underrate him a bit, let name him in the list now.

      Delete
  27. VLASTIMIL KOPECKY- One of the best technical player in Slavia and Czech football history, Vlasta was a player with excellent ball control, fast with the ball, agile, very good passing, great vision to created attack but also often help to defense. He was a very good shooter and despite his small stature, he was good heading ability. Together with Pepi Bican, he became a dangerous attack line and make Slavia very feared team at the time.
    In his country he played for Slavia Prague, for which he scored 252 league goals in 325 matches (1931/32-1950). He is the second highest Czech league goalscorer in history, only Josef Bican has scored more goals in the Czech league. Died of heart attack on football pitch.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. According to main idea in Czech Wikipedia, Vlasta Kopecký was one of the most technical footballers in our history - though smaller stature, excellent hlavičkář, was also an excellent shooter and passer. Played on the left clutch positions, but winger or defender. For his football and character traits became unforgettable personalities just Slavia Prague. In a survey of the Italian newspaper La Gazetta dello Sport from 1939, was named as the best winger in Europe. He set many record of Slavia prague for oldest players proved his longevity.
      As he was one of the best players in his position and his era, I’d name him in the list in forward category although articles describes him as winger but he primarily played as inside-left as I check and also will include him in all-time Czechoslovakia squad.

      Delete
    2. I told you. I watched him. And I looked and Jesper Olsen, Marcel Raducanu and Frank Arnesen. Unfortunately, I have not looked Studnicka. But they told me a lot about him.

      Delete
    3. And I have watched several times and Frane Matosic and Darko Pančev. And God is my witness how Matosic was better!

      Delete
  28. MARCEL RADUCANU-One of the best technicians in the history of Bundesliga, if not the best one. And surely the best dribbler of all times to play in Germany. Raducanu was classic playmaker, not too fast but with excellent ball control, good passing and shot but he was very selfish and always exaggerated with his neverending dribblings. After playing for Steaua Bucureşti in the '70s, when he won two championships and also two Romanian Cups, Răducanu defected following a match in Dortmund, West Germany in 1981. The finest hour of Raducanu’s all too short senior international career arrived with the World Cup qualification game from UEFA Group IV contested at the Stadionul National in Bucharest on October 15, 1980. After completely deceiving the England defender with a fake left-footed shot, Raducanu deftly cut the ball back and rifled a low drive past the diving FC Liverpool goalkeeper RAY CLEMENCE for the game’s first goal in the 35th minute as Romania went on to claim a memorable 2-1 win. Raducanu, who had been named his country’s Footballer of the Year in 1980, soon became disillusioned after not getting on the field for the return game with England at Wembley, a goalless draw, in April of 1981

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Raducanu is rated only one international-class season. As you described his exceptional skill, I’d assume he is full of talent but not much efficient contribution to his team.

      Delete
  29. JESPER OLSEN- Any footballer nicknamed "de Vlo" (the Fly in Dutch) would automatically be assumed to be a player mostly basing his game around fancy dribbling, lightning agility and zipping runs. And very few other footballers in the 80's could probably fit that bill as well as the energetic Danish wide man, Jesper Olsen could.

    Jesper Olsen was a winger of mercurial skill, a player true to the spirit of the famous Ajax Amsterdam academy where he had been nurtured from a young age, moulded after the club's vision of technique, skill and speed sampled together in one body. He had now at the age of 26 for long been the kind of player able to single-handledly make a whole team of opponents feel dizzy once when starting the turbo engine and skipping past the first three defenders with his silky-like bursts of speed and technique. Exactly like the fly he was nicknamed after, he sped around the penalty box, gladly with the all on his feet, driving opponents mad with his unstoppable ability.

    On the national team, Jesper Olsen's legacy will remain as one of the most mythical ones for years to come. He was the player who (arguably) started the Dynamite era (there's a bit of dispute to when this era should be considered to have actually started) by scoring a miracolous solo goal past England's Peter Shilton in stoppage time to keep Denmark alive in the qualification for EURO '84.

    ReplyDelete
  30. JOHAN JAN STUDNICKA- One of the greatest personalities in the history of the Austrian football and let's say "the founder" of the Danubian style of play. Mainly an inside left forward he's mainly famous for his short stature and remarkable bow legs, rocket shots with outside of the boot producing the amazing curle and fantastic dribbling. His style was based on short quick passes, good capacity to read the game and make well timed passes. Jan was good scorer, stocky and masterful strategist, the keepers were scared from his shots.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Studnicka, his biography is interesting as one of the most outstanding figures in history of Austrian football, although it is unclear how much his real performance contribute to his reputation. Articles described he was World Top scorer twice times and I’m not understand the status of awards as world league top scorer list in rsssf do not show his name. I see it is difficult to rate Austrian players who had a peak career in the 1900s when its amateur football played a few games per season and the official league had not held yet. Importantly, his greatness in football is deserved to be honorably mentioned in international legendary museum.

      Delete
  31. FRANK ARNESEN-
    Frank Arnesen was an intimidating player to be put out against. An incontrollable midfielder sourrounded by an astonishing enigma of pace and aggression, he made defenders suffer at the mercy of his feet.

    Sadly he endured a career marred by a injury problems. Specifically his right knee caused him a whole world of trouble and it is very likely that we would have seen way more of this player on the world's greatest pitches if not for the many, many injuries he received through an otherwise impressive career which saw him start out with local club Fremad Amager where he formed a formidable partnership with Søren Lerby.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Costica Stefanescu become one of the top players in his nation in second part of career. He was first caped very late at around 26.5 years old and he was first named in top five Romanian player of the year at his 27 years old but he could amaze people to finally finish second place of Romanian player of the year four times and third place four times and I have made profile of Stefanescu in replacement of Dan Coe in all-time Romania squad according to this superiority.

    Refer to this award, I see Belodedici appeared in top five (all in top three) only three times. I assume he had a short peak.

    ReplyDelete
  33. What career had Sorin? Aldair? Buchwald? Khidiatullin was good, but not much of a career. Wilson Piazza ?????? Essien was really weird! Franky Van der Elst was very useful. Al that belongs to the 100? Emerson similar to Van der Elst. Detari ??? What is Detari made? Belloumi, Keita Kofi, Uribe remains a mystery. Why Ginola so high? (a Jesper Olsen no). Recoba-besides talent, I do not know what is offered. Brolin is a similar story as Arnesen. Just as Arnesen had a lot more talent. Hugi, Inzaghi, Berbatov, Salas Torres Bierhoff Polster ??? My friend, are you sure that there is no better? How long did Mendieta? I am very satisfied with the arguments for Dirceu Lopes and Sune Andersson. Andersson I researched. As for Studnička and Kopecky, even Stefanescu. But now I'm not in Chalana, Sorin, Whiteside, Darko Pančev. I understand for Jarni and Mihajlovic. Ze Roberto is also very strange to me. I hope you will find plenty of arguments to be included Poul Nielsen, Alcantara and Harald Nielsen. I send many greetings from former Yugoslavia!

    ReplyDelete
  34. Harald Nielsen was the top scorer of the Danish league (1960) in that one year he played. He was two times the top scorer of the Italian league (1963,1964). He was the top scorer of the Olympics in 1960. At the same Olympics had played Milan Galic, Bora Kostic, Gerson, Gianni Rivera, Ernst Pohl, Florian Albert, Janos Göröcs. Harald Nielsen was 2 times top scorer Mitropa Cup (1962,1963). Caltex Sportsman Dell'Anno 1963, 1964 The best sportsman of Denmark 1959. He was the best Danish footballer in 1959 and 1961. In 1960 there was no choice for the best players. After,not enter the competition because it's a pro. He received many honorary awards in Italy and Denmark. With Bologna was Italian champion and winner of the Mitropa Cup. He was a champion of Denmark. Mitropa Cup finalist. Silver medal with Denmark at the Olympic Games. His move from Bologna to Inter in 1967 was until then the most expensive transfer in historyof football. For the national team has played only one year. For that year he played 14 matches and scored 15 goals. And at the age of 17-18. After not allowed to play for Denmark because the law on amateur sport. He was born on 26/10/1941. He was admitted to the Danish "hall of fame". His nickname was "Gold-Harald".Is enough for the first 100? I think that's enough for the first 65! Heh-heh! Many greetings!

    ReplyDelete
  35. Why did you put Sergio Ramos in defensive laterals list? he has been playing at centre-back over 4 years after some advices from Platini that he would be one of great defender with that position

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. OK, He recently reach his peak career with CB but it is rather short period and when retrospect to the previous ten years, he is too far to be the top defenders in the world as CB. When I recall his SB performance, I think he is more fit to this role with greater stability in defensive task.

      Delete
  36. Where is Fulvio Bernardini?. Great playmaker!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks you for this player ! I just ever heard of his name and when I read article about his style and ability, he is described as one of the most versatile Italian players ever. However, I really doubt on his consistency when he won only 23 caps.

      Delete
  37. Karl Aage Hansen deserve better!

    ReplyDelete
  38. That he should not be a minus. He played 26 matches for Italy. In these times of incredible reasons were sufficient. Bernardini is included in Italian "hall of fame" and Roma also. It is certainly the best Italian playmaker before world war II.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. OK, Let me study more. If you have more info to confirm you suggestion, please give me a link.

      Delete
  39. ARGENTINA-ludovico bidolglio,francisco olazar
    AUSTRIA-josef blum,franz hasil,jan studnicka,karl zischek,erich probst
    BELGIUM-louis van hege,luc nilis
    BOSNIA-asim ferhatovic
    BRAZIL-renato,luizinho,fausto
    BULGARIA-nikola kotkov,georgi sokolov,todor diev,nikola mutafchiev
    CHESKA-jaroslav burgr,cestmir vycpalek,josef silny,jiri sobotka
    COLOMBIA-efrain sanchez,ivan cordoba,arnoldo iguaran
    CROATIA-dragutin vrdjuka,zvonimir monsider,robert jarni,ivan buljan,ivica surjak,alen boksic,frane matosic,leo lemesic
    DENMARK-frank arnesen,jesper olsen, jorgen sorensen,poul nielsen,harald nielsen,helmuth sobirk,jon dahl tomasson
    ENGLAND-vivian woodward,tommy taylor,frank robertrs,george elliot,bobby parker
    FRANCE-jules dewaquez,joseph ujlaki,nestor combin
    GERMANY-willibald kress,werner liebrich,mesut ozil
    GREECE-giorgios sideris
    HOLLAND-jean de natris,bertus de harder,piet van reenen
    HUNGARY-ferenc plattko,jozsef fogl,sandor matrai,jozsef banas,lazslo budai,andras torocsik,jeno karoly
    IRELAND-steve heighway
    ITALY-fabio cudicini,roberto rosato,danielle de rossi,fulvio bernardini,luigi cevenini,guglielmo gabetto,amadeo amadei
    NORWAY-thorbjorn svensson,per bredesen,tom lund,roald jensen,jorgen juve
    PERU-jose soriano
    POLAND-zygfried szoltysik
    PORTUGAL-jose manuel pepe
    ROMANIA-silviu bindea,marcel raducanu,dudu georgescu
    RUSSIA-fedor selin,vasili trofimov,vsevolod bobrov,mikhail butusov
    SCOTLAND-billy mcneill,tommy gemmell,jimmy quinn,archie stark,gary mcalister,richard gough
    SERBIA-branislav ivanovic,aleksandar tirnanic,ivica bek
    SPAIN-bernardo migueli,jose maria belauste,luis regueiro,juanito,paulino alcantara,rafael pichichi,manuel sanchis
    SWEDEN-ake johansson,bjorn nordqvist,sune andersson,arne selmosson,ralf edstrom,hasse jeppson,erik borjesson,gunnar andersson,sven jonasson,filip johansson
    SWITZERLAND-max abegglen,charles antenen,alfred bickel
    URUGUAY-alfredo foglino,hugo de leon,diego godin,ruben paz
    WALES-mark hughes
    Some big names that you do not have on your lists. Ciao!

    ReplyDelete
  40. Do you know who is the youngest player on this list?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You means youngest player in the present or youngest debut ever ?

      Delete
    2. Youngest player in the present.

      Delete
  41. No Okocha? Who is better in your opinion, Okocha or Djalminha?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Okocha is generally more useful to the specific small team while Djalminha is also by far a greater individual technical player. I still believe Okocha is not great enough to play for Brazil national team, would be trouble in adjustment to Brazilian's unusual style of play. Djalminha did an OK jobs but everyone know Brazil had too many classy players and Djalminha finally won only 14 caps.

      Delete
    2. Who would you say is a better dribbler and entertainer?

      Delete
    3. Djalminha for sure as he was capable to confront the opponents in dangerous area while Okocha stay in deeper or wider area and several times he get pass player in more comfortable situation.

      Delete
  42. You forgot to change Laudrup front Suarez

    ReplyDelete
  43. Hi! Can you name some classic 10s like Riquelme, Rui Costa and others? Players with no defensive duties, static, slow, who play "in the whole" and have great creativity. Glenn Hoddle probably?
    That's dying breed in today's game, they are just too specialized, some "leftovers" are Ganso, and Gourcouff. But i like that style so i just want to watch that kind of players, can you name some more, i mean some historic classic 10s. But no Maradona's, Pele's and others who were a lot more than just distributors and set-piece takers.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, Hoddle will be in the same categorization. Other obvious names would be Netzer, Liedholm, Cueto, Giresse, Dobrin, Ademir Da Guia, Scifo, Alex James, etc

      Delete
    2. Thank you.

      Delete
  44. I'm thinking of "enganche", that kind of players.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Would you say that Zidane and Deyna could be classified as "enganche"?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Zidane is explicitly fit to enganche style. Deyna is a mixture between majority of enganche and minority of trequartista, several times move himself close to penalty area.

      Delete
    2. Thanks. But is Zidane just fit for the role or would you say he played it in majority of his career? I would say that he did play it.

      Delete
    3. It is unquestionable since Zidane is naturally a pure playmaker and rarely played in other position.

      Delete
  46. Solomon Tesfay30/03/2015, 03:27

    I've been a huge fan of your work for a long time now. I just wanted to say thank you for the well thought out, researched and organized information. The time and energy you put into all of this is very much appreciated.

    I also wanted to ask why this particular list says 10x100? Aren't there only 9 positions listed? Am I missing something or isn't 9x100 a more appropriate title?

    Well, if you need help with anything or are looking for volunteers, assistants, researchers or anything like that, I'm more than willing to help at anytime.
    Thanks again man.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I also thank you for your mention. Have we never talked in any forum before ?

      It was my dream to create and develop the project at best to fulfill my overwhelming passion of the game. Although I found the main obstacles of unavailability of some evidences, too large size of the work and complexity of football history but I finally never give up since it has been penetrated to my blood and brain. Now I'm working for an implementation project and have solved the problem of historical irregularity until it has been steadied and would show the result in the next month as plan.

      That is a mistake ! and no one ask me before, it is really nine not ten so I need to revise.

      I'm appreciated your support. Now I have a plan of implementation project of the memorial of football victory which is planed to start in the second half of this year and it is a huge project of calculation to conclude standard of league in any era but it will be a tedious jobs and that's why I personally would not like to bother you.

      Delete
  47. How Tevez, Thiago Silva and others excellent players missing? Both them are affecting a lots on their team with high peak performance and they also has won many trophies, receive a high assessment from fans and media each year. Maybe you rate players from old times too high, when football was not popular and difficult like nowadays

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really forget to update for these two players since they're not qualify for the list when it was first created. Now their further great seasons could lead them to make the list. Let consider their place.

      Delete
    2. what about Thiago Motta, Pepe, Valdes, Carrick, Ivanovic, Nani, De Rossi, Busquets, Pique, Kroos, Marcelo,... and others successful players in late 2000s

      Delete
    3. Only De Rossi and Kroos would be considered. Kroos has not collect great seasons enough in the standard of players in the list. As I check progression of De Rossi's progression, I'm OK to include him.

      Delete
  48. Zé Roberto (Brazil) no is Winger, is box-ti- box midfield.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. He played as a side-midfielder in his peak career with Leverkusen before switch to central midfielder position in the late career.

      Delete
  49. wow, suarez has climbed far away and now he can comparable with many legends while he's only 28. That was a good choice to join Barca. Hope you can look after the other stars who are playing in present days, Naratorn

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Luis Suarez will be named in top 50 Best Forwards in main category since he has achieved world-class seasons and his national team career is better than many in the list.

      Delete
  50. Where's Guti, Morientes, Steve McManaman,...They're all world class players and in my region they've been called legend, who made much success for Real Madrid in Galacticos I.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Eden Hazard, best premier league player award from PFA, overcomes lots of stars like Sanchez, Fabregas, Aguero,... and the most important element for Chelsea to win the premier league

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I agree it is time to name Hazard here.

      Delete
  52. Dear, Readers

    The 9x100 ranking list has been updated based on scorecard. For players who are ranked outside top 50 by major category, I plan to improve by advanced comparison techniqye in the next year.

    ReplyDelete
  53. So as you stand , all of Labruna,VanHimst,Bochini,Giresse,Riquelme,Jair,Vieira,Tigana,Szepan,Peucelle,Keizer,Corbatta,Johnstone,Santamaria,Bergomi,Kholer,DaGuia and Pffaf are better football players than Arsenio Erico in your opinion?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They just have a better career and is clearly inferior to Erico in the peak.

      Delete
    2. Yes I know you rated Erico better in his peak , but bassically with the new implementations , all of those players are better then him in your opinion?

      Delete
    3. They're better because Erico never played in international official match. In only domestic, Erico get higher points than all of your mentioned names although it is not far different enough as Erico's domestic career is relatively short.

      Delete
  54. Don't you think that Salvatore Schillaci should be here?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Certainly not, he was just great in the 1990 World Cup and his club career is just average.

      Delete
  55. Mesut Ozil should definitely be in top 50-60 playmakers.

    ReplyDelete
  56. What about Giorgio Chiellini?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As I check the rating in dbscalcio, he is not qualified.

      Delete
  57. Would you rate 2011-12 Pirlo season as world class?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes in my database, he achieved ordinary world-class in that season. Another one is the 2006 - 2007.

      Delete
  58. Do you think there is a chance Buffon will overcome Zoff? There's been talk he will play three more years before retiring.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Buffon is now not inferior to Zoff in term of achievement but I see Zoff has a higher peak. I always consider Buffon has a limitation to reach the high ball at the top corner. I never see he save likes that but his ability to read the game is considered as the best ever. He surely has a chance. At 36 years old, he still sustain his figure and his agility is still helpful. Anyway, the opportunity of him to qualify for deeper round in international football is questionable since Pirlo has retired.

      Delete
    2. Thanks for your answers :). Do you think Messi can be best ever when he retires? I reckon he'll need more success with Argentina.

      Delete
    3. He has a strong progression to parallel with Maradona but it seems difficult to surpass Pele depend on the remainder part of his career with Argentina. The upcoming Copa America is a compulsory course, he need to get at least semi-finalist with remarkable contribution, otherwise, the opportunity would become harder. I predict he would finish second place.

      Delete
    4. I mean second place best ever, not Copa America anyway.

      Delete
    5. And Ronaldo? I think he could end up in top 10, although it will be hard because of the skill level.

      Delete
    6. The overwhelming expectation of Real Madrid is a forceful factor for him to sustain his level as much as possible but he is going to decline in speed which he is much dependent. He is likely to surpass the Brazilian Ronaldo, meaning to finish 12th at least. Similar case to Messi, his international country career is needed to improve and I think he has the only chance left to achieve world-class in the 2016 Euro. It would be the most important competition for him.

      Delete
    7. It will be really hard for to do much in 2016, against very strong teams like France, Germany and Spain. Btw, I think Pirlo should be in atleast top 20 playmakers.

      Delete
  59. I asked in another section already, but I can't see the answers in comment section.

    How would you rate top 5 European leagues right now, based on competition level?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I already replied in that section. May you check again ?

      Delete
    2. I'm trying, it says load more comments, and when I click it it doesn't do anything.

      Can you just copy past it here?

      Delete
    3. OK, next time, if you want to comment or check my reply in that section, you just click on the word " Loading", it will show the bottom comments as the most update posts.

      Honesty, I'm not following any league in the most recent season since I have not only been busy on my historical project work but also my task in everyday life. But still, I would reply based on my application of knowledge. 1) La Liga 2) English 3) Bundesliga 4) Italy 5) France
      It should be clear for number one as Barcelona and Real Madrid got deeper round in UCL ad Seviila won Europa League. Also, English league became slightly down when Man Utd and Liverpool declined and statistics tell us average scoring per game of the league is significantly increased despite the same style of play.

      Delete
    4. Ok, I personally think that Serie A is stronger than Bundesliga, obviously Bundesliga has Bayern, but when you look at the lower teams, I think Serie A is overall more competitive. (especially if you factor in the fact that Bundesliga has 18 teams.)

      Delete
    5. You're probably right. I'm not in a good position to judge that. Anyway, When AC Milan and Inter Milan has a big decline, the league is rather effected by them.

      Delete
  60. Who would you rate as the best centre back in world right now? There really hasn't been a truly world class center back for a while now. For me it would someone out of Thiago Silva, Kompany, Chiellini and Hummels.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I agree on the names but I see Chiellini is the least tough within a group. Sergio Ramos is not that tough as he is named in FIFPro World XI prolifically but he has a great understanding of the game.

      Delete
    2. What do you think of Andrea Barzagli?

      Delete
    3. He is just lucky to play in the less competitive era of Italian football. He might not capped even once time if born to play in the 1990s. Defenders like Materazzi is tougher than him for my eyes.

      Delete
  61. Who do you think has the most potential for a great career out of young players in the world right now?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It must be Pogba. Although it is unnecessary that a great young player would sustain his great performance through the career but he already achieved three excellent seasons. His completion of playing convince to predict he would be the best central midfielder in the second half 2010s easily.

      James Rodriguez has a high talent but he moved to Real Madrid rather too early.

      Delete
    2. Do you think Hazard could be better than C.Ronaldo?

      Delete
    3. He is not a young player anymore with 24 years old. I don't think he could overtake C.Ronaldo as his international career is just to develop/

      Delete
    4. And what about Neymar?

      Delete
    5. I afraid that he cannot reach full potential as long as staying M-S-N forward line because the more top players the more share of impact level. But still, Messi may play deeper in the late career allowing Neymar to get more decisive role.

      Delete
  62. Why does Zoff have more domestic club points than Buffon? Is it because of competitiveness of the league?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is primarily based om media rating in Dbscalcio.

      Delete
  63. Who do you think has most potential out of young goalkeepers today? (De Gea included)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As criteria of young players would be under-23 based on olympic games criteria. De Gea is not young player anymore. Ter Stegan has passed his full 23 years old, he is also outside extent of consideration. I'm not really sure who has the most potential as I've not followed many of league.

      Delete
  64. If Argentina win Copa America 2015, Di Maria must be somewhere in top 100 offensive lateral. His career is great enough!

    ReplyDelete
  65. Where are the Neville's brothers and others Manchester United legends in 1992 era. They won the triple in 1998 and deserved to be here.

    ReplyDelete
  66. Hierro is far too high on this list. AND Puyol is placed too low on the defenders list

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The fact that he was slow and there are a ton of defenders tougher than him but his contribution on passing and scoring help to raise his level of performance.

      Puyol was inconsistent in both of my watch and rating in dbscalcio.

      Delete
    2. Seems like you have an interesting ranking scheme for evaluating central defenders.

      Hierro's contributions in build-up and passing was remarkable. Sure I'd give him that. But I've seen numbers of forwards beating out Hierro easily; ironically making Casillas to become one of the greatest GK of his era. And yet you've placed Hierro above Gentile and Alan Hansen. He should be level with Ferarra at most.

      As for Puyol, he deserves a little more than staying below Ferdinand. Must be alongside with Adams, or Sol Campbell at least.

      Meanwhile, I was shocked to see Hyypia making into the greatest 100. I'd rather put Raphael Marquez or Jamie Carragher in the all time best central defenders just so you know...

      Otherwise, nice job.

      Delete
    3. I interpret that you give offensive ability for defender in a very minor weight. I give it as a moderate importance when Hierro could score decisive goals in many time and Real Madrid and Spain exploit his accurate passing from the back-line. Gentile is much better than him in defensive level but has nothing to parallel Hierro is offensive quality. I easily agree his overall ability is not superior to Ferrara but performance is significantly depended on the given opportunity and Ferrara is limited in opportunity of international country career.

      Hyypia is more consistent than other names outside top 100. He has better than Carragher and Marquez in air and positional sense although he is too slow. Media rating also give him much higher than Carragher and R.Marquez in average point by season.

      The ranks with below top 50 in the major hall of immortal has not been implemented and just based on a large-scale consideration. I plan to review them by comparison technique in the next year.

      Delete
  67. Billy Lidell is so low! He is with no doubt better than Hazard adn Bale and many others in front of him.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Is it because he played lost of seasons in second division? Hazard still hasn't played the number of seasons in fisrt division as Billy Liddell and also i think that Liddell is a better player.

      Delete
    2. I'll keep this point to review in the next plan. Now really have no time to manage with a ton of players outside the major hall.

      Delete
  68. Who would be biggest underachievers for you? Let's limit it to players on 9x100 list but not in major hall of fame. Players who should have accomplished a lot more based solely on their talent and ability.

    ReplyDelete
  69. Interesting question. There are many names come to my brain. Georges Best will be the best example of an underachiever. Stanley Matthews is the best player with lowest achievement in overall career. Other obvious names will be Jim Baxter, Milos Milutinovic, Rene Pontoni, Dragan Stojkovic, etc.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks. But i'm not quite sure what you meant about Matthews. Is it the same as with Best or did you want to say something else?

      Delete
    2. Matthews is underachiever in case achievement is measured by number of winning trophy. The gap between ability and trophy is the highest and higher than that of George Best who also should have won a lot more trophy.

      When achievement is not defined as a trophy but personal career performance, George Best become the strongest contender of this status.

      Delete
    3. Oh, I understand I meant the gap between performance and ability. So that's George Best. What about players outside of major hall of fame?

      Delete
    4. Let check and will reply tomorrow.

      Delete
    5. Have you checked?

      Delete
    6. Sorry for late. Please give me more time. I have been very busy.

      Delete
    7. No problem.

      Delete
  70. I think Scweinsteiger could be higher. Also, what about Sergio Ramos? Is he gaining points only for central defender now?

    ReplyDelete